CIV 103
Who is an expert? How to identify one and test what they say
What makes a person an expert and in what, six questions to put to any expert, how the courts decide whom to hear and how they hear Elders, and how to weigh the experts met in the news and online.
4 lessons14 hours12 questions
Begin the first lesson Sample certificateYou will be able to
- Say what makes a person an expert, and in what field
- Put six questions to any claim made on an expert’s word
- Explain how a court decides whether to hear an expert, and how it hears an Elder
- Write an expert file on a person quoted in the news
The course in a short lecture
Lessons
- 01What an expert is3 questions · with a primary source
- 02Six questions for any expert3 questions · with a primary source
- 03Experts before the courts, and Elders3 questions · with a primary source
- 04Experts in the news, online and in the Nation’s work3 questions · with a primary source
Activities
| Young learners | Ask an older relative what they know best, and who taught them. |
|---|---|
| Middle school | Name three people whose word you rely on, each one’s field, and how you know. |
| University | Put the six questions to one expert quoted in the news. |
| Law school | Brief a court’s reasons for qualifying an expert, and write an expert file. |
Official description and materials
1.5 University credits · 14 learner hours · ≈ 0.5 ECTS. How credits work →
Official course descriptionCourse outlineTeacher’s guideSheet · Young learnersSheet · Middle schoolSheet · UniversitySheet · Law school
Read further
- Plato, Apology of Socrates, translated by Benjamin Jowett
- Douglas Walton, Appeal to Expert Opinion: Arguments from Authority (Penn State University Press, 1997)
- Alvin I. Goldman, “Experts: Which Ones Should You Trust?” Philosophy and Phenomenological Research 63 (2001)
- R. v. Mohan, [1994] 2 S.C.R. 9
- White Burgess Langille Inman v. Abbott and Haliburton Co., 2015 SCC 23
- Mitchell v. M.N.R., 2001 SCC 33
- Inquiry into Pediatric Forensic Pathology in Ontario, Report (2008)
- The National Books: The Style Book (Book XXXIV)
At four levels
Ages 5 to 9
- Hear the story and colour it: What an expert is
- Hear the story and colour it: Six questions for any expert
- Hear the story and colour it: Experts before the courts, and Elders
Grades 6 to 8
- Read a source and explain: What an expert is
- Read a source and explain: Six questions for any expert
- Read a source and explain: Experts before the courts, and Elders
Undergraduate and up
- Analyse, with sources cited: What an expert is
- Analyse, with sources cited: Six questions for any expert
- Analyse, with sources cited: Experts before the courts, and Elders
Law students and counsel
- Brief the law: What an expert is
- Brief the law: Six questions for any expert
- Brief the law: Experts before the courts, and Elders
Standards
This course follows the University’s standards (set one): a Master Content Card, the universal competencies and a curriculum map. How the standards work →
Essential questions, rising in demand
- What makes a person an expert, and in what?
- What six questions test a claim made on an expert’s word?
- Write an expert file on one person quoted in the news, and say how much weight their word deserves.
Claims and who contests them
- Claim. What speakers, Elders and families carry is expertise, and is tested by the recognition of their own community. Contested by: Courts and universities long counted only written records and credentials, and many still give oral knowledge less weight.
Curriculum map
| Level | Ontario and Canada | International level |
|---|---|---|
| Young learners | Ontario: Social Studies Gr 5, Strand B: The Role of Government and Responsible Citizenship | ISCED 1 (primary) |
| Middle school | Ontario: Gr 8 History (political thinking in inquiry); political thinking (political significance · objectives and results · stability and change · political perspective) | ISCED 2 (lower secondary) |
| Secondary | Ontario: CHV2O Civics and Citizenship (Gr 10); CPW4U Canadian and World Politics (Gr 12) | ISCED 3 (upper secondary) |
| University | Ontario Undergraduate Degree Level Expectations; CMEC Canadian Degree Qualifications Framework | ISCED 6 (bachelor’s) |
| Law school | FLSC National Requirement; TRC Call to Action 28 | ISCED 7 (professional, J.D.) |
National: TRC Calls to Action 62–63; CMEC Canadian Degree Qualifications Framework (2007). Global: UN SDG 4, target 4.7 (citizenship education); UNDRIP art. 18.