Courses · CIV 103 Who is an expert? How to identify one and test what they say · Course outline
For curriculum departments
CIV 103 Who is an expert? How to identify one and test what they say
A course outline in the form institutions use, so a department can assess this course for adoption, as a module, or for transfer credit.
Keep this outline. It may be needed later for credit transfer, certification or employment.
Calendar description
What makes a person an expert and in what, six questions to put to any expert, how the courts decide whom to hear and how they hear Elders, and how to weigh the experts met in the news and online. Taught from the instruments and the Nation’s Register; where a lesson sets out the Nation’s reading of an instrument or case, it says so and gives the source, and learners test it against that source.
Particulars
- Faculty
- Civics
- Lessons
- 4, each with a reading, key terms and a self-check
- Learner hours
- 14; as a module of a term course, see ready-made term courses
- Level
- Written at four levels; this outline is for University (ISCED 6 (bachelor’s))
- Languages
- English; French and Kanien’kéha editions as they are issued
- Programmes
- MU 2600 Method and Evidence
- General education theme
- Civic life (proposed, by Ontario’s five themes)
- Delivery
- Online and self-paced. Where a seminar or moot is held, it is scheduled, in person or by video.
- Learning activities
- Reading, a short lecture with captions, work on a primary source, a self-check in every lesson, an activity at each of four levels, and a seminar or moot.
- Standing
- A draft, awaiting approval by the Chair of the faculty. Version 1.0.
- Fees
- Free for registered members of the Nation. Institutions adopt by agreement with the University.
Learning outcomes
| By the end, a learner can | Bloom’s level | Ontario Degree Level Expectation |
|---|---|---|
| Say what makes a person an expert, and in what field | Understand | Depth and breadth of knowledge |
| Put six questions to any claim made on an expert’s word | Understand | Depth and breadth of knowledge |
| Explain how a court decides whether to hear an expert, and how it hears an Elder | Understand | Depth and breadth of knowledge |
| Write an expert file on a person quoted in the news | Apply | Application of knowledge |
Schedule
| Unit | Topic | Source |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | What an expert is | Plato, Apology of Socrates, 22d: Socrates on the craftsmen |
| 2 | Six questions for any expert | Federal Courts Rules, Code of Conduct for Expert Witnesses, sections 1 and 2 |
| 3 | Experts before the courts, and Elders | R. v. Mohan: a properly qualified expert |
| 4 | Experts in the news, online and in the Nation’s work | The Style Book (Book XXXIV): two rules on sources |
Assessment
| Component | Weight |
|---|---|
| Self-checks, every lesson | 15% |
| Primary-source analysis | 25% |
| Seminar or moot participation | 15% |
| Final essay or brief | 45% |
Marked to an essay rubric (university) or a moot marking guide (law), in the four Achievement Chart categories where the course is taught in a school: Knowledge and Understanding, Thinking, Communication, Application.
Topics, terms and objectives
By the end of each lesson a learner can explain its key terms and answer its three questions.
1 · What an expert is
Key terms: Expert, Field, Knowledge keeper, Trespassing.
- What does “in a particular field” mean for expertise?
- What fault did Socrates find in the craftsmen?
- What does a title tell you?
2 · Six questions for any expert
Key terms: Appeal to expert opinion, Credential, Conflict of interest, Consensus.
- Which question catches the most false authority?
- What should always be known about an expert?
- How does a lone voice prove the others wrong?
3 · Experts before the courts, and Elders
Key terms: Opinion evidence, Gatekeeper, Cross-examination, Oral history.
- Does the law require an expert to hold a degree?
- To whom does an expert witness owe a duty?
- When are oral histories admissible?
4 · Experts in the news, online and in the Nation’s work
Key terms: False balance, Peer review, Preprint, Expert file.
- What does a reporter do by quoting an expert?
- When is giving “both sides” equal space misleading?
- How should the answer of a writing program be treated?
Essential employability skills
- Communication
- Practised and assessed in this course.
- Numeracy
- Not applicable.
- Critical thinking and problem solving
- Not applicable.
- Information management
- Not applicable.
- Interpersonal
- Practised and assessed in this course.
- Personal
- Not applicable.
Grading
Work is graded in percentages, against the rubric, by the weights above, and marks are not scaled. Proposed scale: A, 80 to 100; B, 70 to 79; C, 60 to 69; D, 50 to 59; F, below 50. Proposed pass mark for a course: 50 per cent.
Prior learning and transfer
A learner who already has the learning of this course, from a course completed elsewhere, from work, from study on their own, or from life, may ask to show it against the outcomes above and be given the course without taking it. It is shown by a challenge, by a portfolio, or by speaking or doing it; credit is for learning that is shown, never for experience alone (proposed, in the draft directive on standards and credits). See prior learning assessment and recognition. Another institution decides for itself what credit it grants for this course.
Citation
Chicago Manual of Style, 18th edition (notes and bibliography).
Rules of the course
The full list is in the outline as a document.
- Use of AI
- Proposed, after FAC 105. Self-checks are done unaided. In written work a tool may be used to find sources or to tidy a draft the learner wrote, and that use is disclosed in a sentence at the end. The learner answers for every fact and source. No personal information, nothing confidential, and nothing of the Nation’s that is not public is given to a tool. A teacher may set a stricter rule.
- No surveillance
- The University uses no software that watches learners, and no program that claims to detect machine-written text. No learner is found in breach on such a program’s word (FAC 105, FAC 107).
- Seminars and group work
- Proposed. A seminar or moot is marked for each learner’s own part. Cameras are not required. A learner who misses a scheduled seminar takes the next one, or does a written alternative. A seminar is moved for a learner’s ceremony, observance or bereavement (FAC 104, FAC 107).
- Review of a mark
- Proposed. A learner may ask the marker to explain a mark. If that does not settle it, the learner may ask the Chair of the faculty, in writing and within thirty days, to have the work marked again by a second marker. A further appeal goes to the Dean, whose decision is entered in the Register with its reasons.
- Complaints
- Proposed. A complaint about how a course was taught goes to the Chair of the faculty, and then to the Dean.
Changes to this outline
Any change is made as a new version, approved the same way, and every version is kept. Proposed: a change to how the course is assessed does not apply to a learner who has already begun, unless the learner agrees.
Policies
- Academic integrity: the institution’s own policy applies; every source is cited.
- Accessibility: the course meets WCAG 2.2 AA and is designed to Universal Design for Learning; accommodations follow the institution’s policy and the AODA.
- Indigenous knowledge: the Nation’s positions are taught as its readings, attributed, with the instrument; nothing sacred or restricted is taught.
- Privacy: the University keeps nothing a learner writes.