Courses · CIV 103 Who is an expert? How to identify one and test what they say · Lesson 1 of 4
What an expert is
Lecture 1 of 4 · about 7 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- What does “in a particular field” mean for expertise?
- What fault did Socrates find in the craftsmen?
- What does a title tell you?
Nobody can check everything. We take a doctor’s word on a medicine, a surveyor’s on a boundary, a speaker’s on a word. To rely on people who know more than we do is sensible, and every court, newsroom and government does it. The skill is in choosing whom to rely on, and for what. CIV 102 taught how to weigh a claim. This course teaches how to weigh the person making it.
An expert is a person who has knowledge or skill in a particular field well beyond what most people have, and who can be shown to have it. Each part of that sentence does work. “In a particular field”: nobody is an expert in general. “Can be shown”: expertise is a fact about a person that others can check, and saying so does not make it so.
There are three roads to it. The first is study: years of training, tested by examination, ending in a degree or a licence. The second is practice: long experience of doing the thing, shown by a record of work that held up. The third is recognition by a community of what a person carries: a speaker who grew up in the language, an Elder who was taught a history by those who lived it, a maker taught by her grandmother. The third road has no certificate, and it is none the weaker for that. A family’s knowledge of who its people were is often better than any register, as HIS 102 taught, and this University prints each word of the language as its source gives it and coins none.
The oldest account of testing experts is printed below. Socrates, on trial in Athens in 399 BC, told the court how he had gone about examining those with a name for wisdom. The politicians and the poets could not explain what they claimed to know. The craftsmen did know their crafts, and he said so. Their fault was a different one: being good at one thing, they took themselves to be authorities on everything else.
That fault has not changed in twenty-four centuries. A physicist is not an expert on vaccines, nor a physician on climate, nor a lawyer on history, nor a historian on law. Writers on the subject now call it trespassing. When a person of real standing in one field pronounces on another, weigh the pronouncement as you would anyone’s.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Expert” means. Then read on.
It helps to say what an expert is not. A witness saw something happen; that is knowledge of an event and not of a field. An advocate argues for a side, and may know a great deal, but is bound to the side. An official holds an office: a title tells you what a person may decide, and tells you nothing about what they know. A celebrity is known. A confident speaker is confident. None of these is expertise, though any of them may be found in the same person as it.
Confidence deserves a word, because it misleads so often. A well-known study of 1999 found that the people who scored lowest on tests of a skill were the ones who most overestimated how well they had done. Real experts tend to speak with more care: they say what is settled, what is disputed, and where their own knowledge stops. “I do not know” is a mark in a person’s favour.
Lastly, to rely on an expert is not to obey one. An expert’s opinion is evidence, usually good evidence, and it is weighed with the rest. You may ask for reasons, seek a second opinion, and decide. What you may not sensibly do is treat every opinion as equal to every other, as though forty years of study counted for nothing.
To begin, list five people whose word you rely on for something. Beside each write the field, which of the three roads they came by, and how you know.
The source
At last I went to the artisans, for I was conscious that I knew nothing at all, as I may say, and I was sure that they knew many fine things; and here I was not mistaken, for they did know many things of which I was ignorant, and in this they certainly were wiser than I was. But I observed that even the good artisans fell into the same error as the poets;—because they were good workmen they thought that they also knew all sorts of high matters, and this defect in them overshadowed their wisdom.Plato, Apology of Socrates, 22d: Socrates on the craftsmen · Translated by Benjamin Jowett (1871).
Key terms
- Expert
- A person with knowledge or skill in a particular field well beyond the ordinary, which can be shown.
- Field
- The subject within which a person’s expertise lies.
- Knowledge keeper
- A person recognised by a community as carrying its knowledge.
- Trespassing
- Speaking with an expert’s confidence outside one’s own field.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Expert, Field, Knowledge keeper, Trespassing.