Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · CIV 103 Who is an expert? How to identify one and test what they say · Lesson 2 of 4

Six questions for any expert

Lecture 2 of 4 · about 7 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. Which question catches the most false authority?
  2. What should always be known about an expert?
  3. How does a lone voice prove the others wrong?

When someone says “experts say” or “according to Dr. So-and-so”, an argument is being made: this person is an expert, this person says so, therefore it is so. The Canadian philosopher Douglas Walton spent a career on arguments of this kind, and gave six questions that test them. They take a few minutes and need no special knowledge.

One: expertise. How good an expert is this? Look for the training, the licence, the years, the published work, and check them where they can be checked. Regulated professions keep public registers. A university will confirm a degree. A real scholar’s work can be found, and has been read by other scholars. Be wary of credentials that cannot be traced, and of titles from bodies nobody has heard of.

Two: field. Is this the expert’s own field? This is the question from the last lesson, and it catches more false authority than any other. Ask it narrowly. A land surveyor is the expert on where a boundary runs, and is not thereby the expert on who owns what lies inside it.

Three: opinion. What exactly did the expert say? Go to their own words, as CIV 102 taught, since experts are misquoted, quoted in part, and quoted years after they changed their minds. An expert who said “this may be so in some cases” has not said that it is so.

Four: trustworthiness. Is there a reason to doubt this expert’s honesty or independence? Ask who pays them, who employs them, and what they stand to gain. A stake does not make a person wrong, and it should always be known. Ask too about their record: have their earlier judgments held up?

The table sets out the six questions. Read across: the question, what to ask, and how to find out.
QuestionAskHow to find outExpertiseHow good an expert is this?Registers, degrees, publishedworkFieldIs it their own field?Compare the claim with thetrainingOpinionWhat exactly did they say?Their own words, in fullTrustAny stake or bias?Funding, employer, recordConsistencyWhat do other experts say?The field’s own reviewsEvidenceWhat is it based on?Data, method and reasons shown

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Credential” means. Then read on.

Five: consistency. What do other experts in the same field say? If nearly all of them agree, a lone voice against them carries a heavy burden. Lone voices are sometimes right, and the way they prove it is with evidence that persuades their colleagues. If the field is truly divided, say so, and distrust anyone who tells you it is settled.

Six: evidence. What is the opinion based on? A real expert can show the grounds: the data, the documents, the method, the reasoning. “Trust me” is no answer from anyone. The rules of Canada’s Federal Court, whose opening words are printed below, turn this into a list. An expert’s report must set out the expert’s qualifications, the facts and assumptions relied on, the reasons for each opinion, the literature and method, any caveats, any matter outside the expert’s field, and any tie to a party. It is a good list to hold any expert to, in a court or out of one.

Some signs should put you on guard at once. The person speaks outside their field. They will not show their evidence. They claim certainty where their own colleagues are divided. Their funding is hidden. Their credentials cannot be found. They answer criticism by attacking the critic. Or they say that all the other experts are in a conspiracy, which is a claim that needs more evidence than any other and usually comes with less.

Apply the six in the other direction too. When an expert says something you would rather not hear, the temptation is to find a reason to dismiss them. If they pass the six questions, the honest course is to take what they say seriously.

To practise, take one expert quoted in this week’s news. Answer the six questions in a sentence each, saying for each how you found out. Note which question was hardest to answer, and why.

The source

An expert witness named to provide a report for use as evidence, or to testify in a proceeding, has an overriding duty to assist the Court impartially on matters relevant to his or her area of expertise. This duty overrides any duty to a party to the proceeding, including the person retaining the expert witness. An expert is to be independent and objective. An expert is not an advocate for a party.
Federal Courts Rules, Code of Conduct for Expert Witnesses, sections 1 and 2 · SOR/98-106, Schedule (rule 52.2).

Key terms

Appeal to expert opinion
An argument that something is so because an expert says so.
Credential
A degree, licence or certificate that can be checked with the body that granted it.
Conflict of interest
A stake that could pull an expert’s judgment away from the evidence.
Consensus
The settled view of nearly all the experts in a field.

Check yourself

1.Which question catches the most false authority?
2.What should always be known about an expert?
3.How does a lone voice prove the others wrong?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Appeal to expert opinion, Credential, Conflict of interest, Consensus.