Courses · CIV 103 Who is an expert? How to identify one and test what they say · Lesson 3 of 4
Experts before the courts, and Elders
Lecture 3 of 4 · about 8 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- Does the law require an expert to hold a degree?
- To whom does an expert witness owe a duty?
- When are oral histories admissible?
Courts have thought longer than anyone about whom to believe, because a court that hears the wrong expert can ruin a life. An ordinary witness may tell a court only what they saw and heard. An expert is allowed to give an opinion, and that is a privilege the court guards.
In 1994, in R. v. Mohan, the Supreme Court of Canada set four conditions before an expert may be heard. The evidence must be relevant. It must be necessary, in that the court could not reach a sound conclusion without it. No other rule of evidence may exclude it. And it must come from a properly qualified expert, whom the Court described in the words printed below. Notice that the description says “study or experience”: the law does not require a degree.
In 2015, in the case known as White Burgess, the Court added what the last lesson called trustworthiness. An expert owes a duty to the court to give opinion evidence that is fair, objective and non-partisan, and must be able and willing to carry it out. An expert who cannot is not heard at all. Ontario’s courts require every expert to sign an acknowledgment of that duty, and the Federal Court’s code says that an expert is not an advocate for a party.
Even then the expert is tested. The judge acts as a gatekeeper, and may keep out an opinion whose risks outweigh its worth. The other side cross-examines, and may call an expert of its own. And the judge decides what weight the opinion deserves, and gives reasons. An expert in court assists the judge. The decision remains the judge’s.
Ontario learned what happens when that testing fails. For years one pathologist was treated as the leading authority on the suspicious deaths of children, and gave evidence in dozens of criminal cases. An inquiry under Justice Stephen Goudge reported in 2008 that he had not been qualified as a forensic pathologist, and that his training in that field was “woefully inadequate”. A review found serious errors in at least twenty of his cases, twelve of which had ended in convictions. Parents and others who cared for children had been found guilty in their deaths on the word of a man speaking outside his field. The inquiry called it a story of failed oversight as much as of one man. For too long nobody had asked the second question.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Opinion evidence” means. Then read on.
The third road to expertise has had a harder time in the courts, which were built around documents. In 1997, in Delgamuukw, the Supreme Court held that the rules of evidence must be adapted so that oral histories stand on an equal footing with written ones. In 2001, in Mitchell, a case brought by a Mohawk of Akwesasne, it said that oral histories are admissible where they are both useful and reasonably reliable, and that they are neither to be undervalued nor strained to carry more than they can support. The Federal Court has since published guidelines for hearing Elders with the respect and the protocol their standing calls for.
Who is an Elder, or a knowledge keeper? The courts leave that, rightly, to the people concerned. The test is recognition: a community knows who carries its knowledge, who taught them, and what they are entitled to speak about. A person who announces himself an Elder to outsiders, and whom the community does not know, has failed the test. The Nation’s Style Book writes Elder with a capital for a recognised Elder, and its rule for stories is that they are told by permission of the teller.
The Nation identifies its own experts in a way the courts would recognise. A surveyor commissioned by the Surveyor General holds a licence that records the person’s name, role, qualifications held elsewhere, scope and term, and every grant and revocation is on the Ledger. Anyone can therefore answer the first two questions about such a person from the record: what they are qualified in, and what they are commissioned to do.
For this lesson, read the reasons of a court in one case where an expert was heard: many are free on CanLII, as LAW 102 showed. Find where the judge says why the expert was qualified, in what field, and how much weight the opinion was given. Write five sentences.
The source
[T]he evidence must be given by a witness who is shown to have acquired special or peculiar knowledge through study or experience in respect of the matters on which he or she undertakes to testify.R. v. Mohan: a properly qualified expert · Supreme Court of Canada, [1994] 2 S.C.R. 9 (Sopinka J.).
Key terms
- Opinion evidence
- A witness’s judgment about what facts mean, which only an expert may give.
- Gatekeeper
- The judge’s part in deciding whether an expert is heard at all.
- Cross-examination
- Questioning of a witness by the other side.
- Oral history
- A people’s account of its past, handed down by word of mouth.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Opinion evidence, Gatekeeper, Cross-examination, Oral history.