Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · CIV 103 Who is an expert? How to identify one and test what they say · Lesson 4 of 4

Experts in the news, online and in the Nation’s work

Lecture 4 of 4 · about 7 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. What does a reporter do by quoting an expert?
  2. When is giving “both sides” equal space misleading?
  3. How should the answer of a writing program be treated?

Most of the experts a citizen meets are met second-hand, in a news story or on a screen. Someone else has chosen them. This lesson is about that choosing: how a reporter should do it, how a reader should judge it, and how the Nation does it for itself.

A reporter who quotes an expert is vouching for them. PUB 102 taught verification, and it applies to people as much as to facts. Before quoting, answer the six questions. In the story, say what the expert’s field is and where they work, and say who funds the work if that bears on it. Quote them on their field and on nothing else. And prefer the expert who studies the question to the one who is quickest to return a call.

There is a trap on the other side. Reporters are trained to give both sides, and when a field is truly divided that is right. When nearly every expert agrees, setting one of them against a lone dissenter as though the matter were open misleads the reader about the state of knowledge. Researchers who studied American newspapers’ coverage of the climate named the result “balance as bias”. The honest course is to report where the weight of expert opinion lies, and to report the dissent in proportion.

Learn the kinds of thing an expert’s opinion can appear in. A study that other experts have reviewed before publication has passed one test, though it is not thereby true. A preprint has not yet been reviewed. A report from an institute may be careful work or advocacy, and the way to tell is to ask who funds the institute. A book for general readers is the author’s own word. A post is a post.

The picture sets the signs of an expert beside the signs to be wary of. Read down each column.
Signs of an expertSpeaks within a fieldShows the evidence and the methodSays what is disputed, and where theirknowledge stopsStake and funding are openSigns to be wary ofSpeaks on everythingSays “trust me”Certain where colleagues are dividedCredentials or funding cannot be found

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Preprint” means. Then read on.

Online, expertise is easy to imitate. A white coat, a title in a profile and a confident manner cost nothing. Check the name against a register. And do not mistake a machine for an expert. A program that writes fluent answers has no training that can be examined, no reputation to lose, and no duty to anyone, and it can be wrong in a perfectly assured voice. Treat what it gives you as a lead to be checked against a source, as FAC 105 teaches, and never as the source.

The Nation’s own practice shows the method at work. Its guide books each carry a section headed “Questions an expert or critic would ask”, and answer them, including the ones they cannot yet answer well. Its Style Book’s rules are printed below: say what a source holds and no more, and state the limits first. And this University lists on its benchmarks page what each faculty still lacks, among them the lessons that await review by a person qualified in the field, and it says what kind of person that is: a lawyer who practises in it, or a knowledge keeper.

Sometimes you will think an expert is wrong. You may be right: experts err, and whole fields have erred. Disagree well. Find out what the expert actually said. Find the evidence against it, from people who are themselves qualified. Say what would change your mind, and ask the expert the same. That is how knowledge improves. Dismissing an expert because the conclusion is unwelcome, or because they belong to the wrong side, is a different activity.

To finish the course, write an expert file of one page on a person quoted as an expert in a story that matters to you. Give the name, the field, and the road by which they came to it. Answer the six questions, with where you found each answer. Say what they are an expert in and what they are not. And say, in one sentence, how much weight you would give their word on the point in the story, and why.

The source

Say what a source holds — no more: a case is cited for what it decided; the Nation’s inference from it is called the Nation’s inference. State the limits first: where an authority cuts against the Nation, the book says so before a critic does.
The Style Book (Book XXXIV): two rules on sources · The National Books, Book XXXIV, section 16: Quoting, citing and checking.

Key terms

False balance
Presenting a lone dissenter as the equal of a settled field.
Peer review
Checking of a study by other experts before it is published.
Preprint
A study made public before other experts have reviewed it.
Expert file
A one-page record of who an expert is, in what field, and how that was checked.

Check yourself

1.What does a reporter do by quoting an expert?
2.When is giving “both sides” equal space misleading?
3.How should the answer of a writing program be treated?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: False balance, Peer review, Preprint, Expert file.