Courses · CIV 103 Who is an expert? How to identify one and test what they say · Teacher’s guide
Teacher’s guide
Who is an expert? How to identify one and test what they say
A plan for every lesson in the six parts of the lesson model that Ontario’s colleges teach (bridge-in, objectives, pre-assessment, participatory learning, post-assessment, summary), with timings, a prompt, the common misreadings to watch for, the learning sheets at four levels and the rubric.
Learning sheets
Lesson plans
Lesson 1 · What an expert is 60 minutes
| 5 min | Bridge-in. Open with the essential question: “What makes a person an expert, and in what?” |
|---|---|
| 5 min | Objectives and pre-assessment. Put the lesson’s three questions on the board and take a show of hands on each |
| 15 min | The lecture. Tell it; do not read it aloud. Stop at each key term, and show the illustration half-way |
| 10 min | Participatory. In pairs, work the primary source: who made it, when, for whom, and what it says |
| 10 min | Participatory. The activity at the class’s level |
| 10 min | Post-assessment. Self-check, then discuss the reason for each answer |
| 5 min | Summary. Return to the three questions; one sentence each on what changed in their thinking |
Prompt: What does a title tell you?
- Watch for: “Experts know every field”. Expertise has edges.
- Watch for: “They did not know their crafts”. They did know their crafts; that was not the fault.
- Watch for: “Nothing at all”. Office and expertise are different things.
Lesson 2 · Six questions for any expert 60 minutes
| 5 min | Bridge-in. Open with the essential question: “What makes a person an expert, and in what?” |
|---|---|
| 5 min | Objectives and pre-assessment. Put the lesson’s three questions on the board and take a show of hands on each |
| 15 min | The lecture. Tell it; do not read it aloud. Stop at each key term, and show the illustration half-way |
| 10 min | Participatory. In pairs, work the primary source: who made it, when, for whom, and what it says |
| 10 min | Participatory. The activity at the class’s level |
| 10 min | Post-assessment. Self-check, then discuss the reason for each answer |
| 5 min | Summary. Return to the three questions; one sentence each on what changed in their thinking |
Prompt: How does a lone voice prove the others wrong?
- Watch for: “How old is the expert?”. Ask it narrowly.
- Watch for: “Their favourite authors”. A stake does not make a person wrong, and it should be known.
- Watch for: “By repeating the claim”. The burden is heavy, and it can be met.
Lesson 3 · Experts before the courts, and Elders 60 minutes
| 5 min | Bridge-in. Open with the essential question: “What makes a person an expert, and in what?” |
|---|---|
| 5 min | Objectives and pre-assessment. Put the lesson’s three questions on the board and take a show of hands on each |
| 15 min | The lecture. Tell it; do not read it aloud. Stop at each key term, and show the illustration half-way |
| 10 min | Participatory. In pairs, work the primary source: who made it, when, for whom, and what it says |
| 10 min | Participatory. The activity at the class’s level |
| 10 min | Post-assessment. Self-check, then discuss the reason for each answer |
| 5 min | Summary. Return to the three questions; one sentence each on what changed in their thinking |
Prompt: When are oral histories admissible?
- Watch for: “Only in criminal cases”. The words are “study or experience”.
- Watch for: “To nobody”. An expert is not an advocate for a party.
- Watch for: “Never”. The Supreme Court in Mitchell, 2001.
Lesson 4 · Experts in the news, online and in the Nation’s work 60 minutes
| 5 min | Bridge-in. Open with the essential question: “What makes a person an expert, and in what?” |
|---|---|
| 5 min | Objectives and pre-assessment. Put the lesson’s three questions on the board and take a show of hands on each |
| 15 min | The lecture. Tell it; do not read it aloud. Stop at each key term, and show the illustration half-way |
| 10 min | Participatory. In pairs, work the primary source: who made it, when, for whom, and what it says |
| 10 min | Participatory. The activity at the class’s level |
| 10 min | Post-assessment. Self-check, then discuss the reason for each answer |
| 5 min | Summary. Return to the three questions; one sentence each on what changed in their thinking |
Prompt: How should the answer of a writing program be treated?
- Watch for: “Hires them”. So the six questions come first.
- Watch for: “When a field is truly divided”. Report where the weight of opinion lies.
- Watch for: “As an expert’s opinion”. It has no training to examine and no duty to anyone.
Rubric for the final task
| Criterion | Level 3 · the standard | Level 4 | Level 2 | Level 1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Knowledge of the sources | Uses the instruments and readings accurately and fully, with no material error. | Exact and complete, including what the sources do not say. | Accurate with minor gaps. | Frequent errors or missing sources. |
| Argument and analysis | States a clear thesis and supports it with evidence from the sources, weighing the main counter-reading. | Original, and answers the strongest counter-reading. | A thesis, thinly supported. | No clear thesis. |
| Citation | Every source cited in Chicago notes and bibliography, so a reader can find each page. | Flawless, including archival sources. | Mostly complete; some lapses. | Missing or unusable citations. |
| Writing | Clear, plain and organised; a reader follows it on one reading. | Concise and memorable. | Readable but uneven. | Hard to follow. |
All answers, with their reasons, are on the Teachers page.