Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · CIV 103 Who is an expert? How to identify one and test what they say · Teacher’s guide

Teacher’s guide

Who is an expert? How to identify one and test what they say

A plan for every lesson in the six parts of the lesson model that Ontario’s colleges teach (bridge-in, objectives, pre-assessment, participatory learning, post-assessment, summary), with timings, a prompt, the common misreadings to watch for, the learning sheets at four levels and the rubric.

Learning sheets

Lesson plans

Lesson 1 · What an expert is 60 minutes

5 minBridge-in. Open with the essential question: “What makes a person an expert, and in what?”
5 minObjectives and pre-assessment. Put the lesson’s three questions on the board and take a show of hands on each
15 minThe lecture. Tell it; do not read it aloud. Stop at each key term, and show the illustration half-way
10 minParticipatory. In pairs, work the primary source: who made it, when, for whom, and what it says
10 minParticipatory. The activity at the class’s level
10 minPost-assessment. Self-check, then discuss the reason for each answer
5 minSummary. Return to the three questions; one sentence each on what changed in their thinking

Prompt: What does a title tell you?

  • Watch for: “Experts know every field”. Expertise has edges.
  • Watch for: “They did not know their crafts”. They did know their crafts; that was not the fault.
  • Watch for: “Nothing at all”. Office and expertise are different things.

Lesson 2 · Six questions for any expert 60 minutes

5 minBridge-in. Open with the essential question: “What makes a person an expert, and in what?”
5 minObjectives and pre-assessment. Put the lesson’s three questions on the board and take a show of hands on each
15 minThe lecture. Tell it; do not read it aloud. Stop at each key term, and show the illustration half-way
10 minParticipatory. In pairs, work the primary source: who made it, when, for whom, and what it says
10 minParticipatory. The activity at the class’s level
10 minPost-assessment. Self-check, then discuss the reason for each answer
5 minSummary. Return to the three questions; one sentence each on what changed in their thinking

Prompt: How does a lone voice prove the others wrong?

  • Watch for: “How old is the expert?”. Ask it narrowly.
  • Watch for: “Their favourite authors”. A stake does not make a person wrong, and it should be known.
  • Watch for: “By repeating the claim”. The burden is heavy, and it can be met.

Lesson 3 · Experts before the courts, and Elders 60 minutes

5 minBridge-in. Open with the essential question: “What makes a person an expert, and in what?”
5 minObjectives and pre-assessment. Put the lesson’s three questions on the board and take a show of hands on each
15 minThe lecture. Tell it; do not read it aloud. Stop at each key term, and show the illustration half-way
10 minParticipatory. In pairs, work the primary source: who made it, when, for whom, and what it says
10 minParticipatory. The activity at the class’s level
10 minPost-assessment. Self-check, then discuss the reason for each answer
5 minSummary. Return to the three questions; one sentence each on what changed in their thinking

Prompt: When are oral histories admissible?

  • Watch for: “Only in criminal cases”. The words are “study or experience”.
  • Watch for: “To nobody”. An expert is not an advocate for a party.
  • Watch for: “Never”. The Supreme Court in Mitchell, 2001.

Lesson 4 · Experts in the news, online and in the Nation’s work 60 minutes

5 minBridge-in. Open with the essential question: “What makes a person an expert, and in what?”
5 minObjectives and pre-assessment. Put the lesson’s three questions on the board and take a show of hands on each
15 minThe lecture. Tell it; do not read it aloud. Stop at each key term, and show the illustration half-way
10 minParticipatory. In pairs, work the primary source: who made it, when, for whom, and what it says
10 minParticipatory. The activity at the class’s level
10 minPost-assessment. Self-check, then discuss the reason for each answer
5 minSummary. Return to the three questions; one sentence each on what changed in their thinking

Prompt: How should the answer of a writing program be treated?

  • Watch for: “Hires them”. So the six questions come first.
  • Watch for: “When a field is truly divided”. Report where the weight of opinion lies.
  • Watch for: “As an expert’s opinion”. It has no training to examine and no duty to anyone.

Rubric for the final task

CriterionLevel 3 · the standardLevel 4Level 2Level 1
Knowledge of the sourcesUses the instruments and readings accurately and fully, with no material error.Exact and complete, including what the sources do not say.Accurate with minor gaps.Frequent errors or missing sources.
Argument and analysisStates a clear thesis and supports it with evidence from the sources, weighing the main counter-reading.Original, and answers the strongest counter-reading.A thesis, thinly supported.No clear thesis.
CitationEvery source cited in Chicago notes and bibliography, so a reader can find each page.Flawless, including archival sources.Mostly complete; some lapses.Missing or unusable citations.
WritingClear, plain and organised; a reader follows it on one reading.Concise and memorable.Readable but uneven.Hard to follow.

All answers, with their reasons, are on the Teachers page.