Courses · REC 101 Reconciliation: the Loyalist Mohawk history and law · The evidence portfolio
The work that closes the course · 3 h
The evidence portfolio
800 to 1,000 words, or its equal in another form, such as a narrated presentation with its transcript.
The task
Choose one bounded claim about a document, a reading of it, or a proposed next step considered in this course. Using three properly cited sources, at least two of them primary and one legal or scholarly, explain what the evidence supports; what it does not establish; one other documented reading, stated fairly; and what further evidence, or whose knowledge, would be needed. Do not decide a question of law. You may agree with the Nation’s reading, disagree with it, or leave it open: you are marked on how you use the evidence.
How to go about it
| Read the prompt, the rubric and the comments on your four notes. | 10 min |
| Choose three sources, two of them primary, and check each against its link. | 30 min |
| Write the portfolio. | 1 h 50 min |
| Check the citations, revise for accuracy and limits, and hand it in. | 30 min |
The rubric
No criterion rewards agreeing or disagreeing with the Nation’s reading.
| Criterion | Weight | Meets the standard | Not yet |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sources and citation | 25% | The sources fit the claim, can be found from the citation, and are cited to the passage. Primary and secondary are told apart, and a transcription is named as one. | A source is cited loosely, or a later summary is used as if it were the document. |
| Reading and reasoning | 25% | The words of each source are given accurately. The claim is bounded and follows from them. | The claim goes further than the words quoted, or a reading is given as the text. |
| Another reading, and what is open | 25% | One other documented reading is stated so that its holders would accept the statement. What the evidence cannot settle is named. | The other reading is missing or misstated. An open question is written as closed. |
| Context and care | 15% | Says whose account is whose. Does not treat different nations and communities as one. Names where a decision or a piece of knowledge belongs to someone else. | Speaks for a community from outside it, or blurs one people into another. |
| Communication | 10% | Clear and ordered, with complete references in Chicago notes and bibliography. | Hard to follow, or references incomplete. |
The four notes
Each lesson ends in a short note with its work on the sources. One rubric serves all four: accuracy in using the sources 40, reasoning 30, attention to limits 20, clarity and citation 10.
How the course is marked
| The four notes and their work, 10 per cent each | 40% |
| The evidence portfolio | 60% |
The four notes and the final written work, the portfolio, are written in My Register and handed in there, and the Register reads each at once against the rubric. A note that meets what its task asks for that can be checked (its length, a source named, its quotations found word for word, what is left open said) is accepted there and then, and the Register’s reading stands as its mark unless the instructor changes it. A note that does not is handed back with what was not found; handed in a second time, it is read by the instructor. The final written work is always decided by the instructor or professor of the course, who confirms the Register’s reading, changes it, or returns the piece once for revision. If it is not passed there is one more attempt, which asks for one thing more. The course is finished when every lesson is read, its test is passed, its four notes are accepted, and the final written work is passed at 50 per cent. No AI is used in written work, unless the learner has finished FAC 105, the University’s course on the ethical use of AI, and the instructor allows it for the course; its use is then declared at handing in.
A second attempt
If the final written work is not passed, you have one more attempt. You have had your instructor’s decision and words, so the second attempt asks for one thing more: a closing part of 100 to 150 words on what you changed and why, bringing in one further source of the course that your first attempt did not use. The Register sets the second attempt beside the first for your instructor, who decides it. The second decision is the one that stands. If it is not passed either, the course is not finished, and may be taken again.