Courses · REC 101 Reconciliation: the Loyalist Mohawk history and law · Lesson 4 of 4
Reconciling on the record
Lecture 4 of 4 · about 6 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- What does the Nation propose reconciliation here is?
- Which instrument provided for ascertainment on oath?
- Why keep every letter and answer in the Register?
The Nation’s proposal is that reconciliation here is record-keeping: finish what the instruments began. Ascertain the class on oath, as 1796 provided. Record the posterity, by either sex, as 1789 provided. Observe the grant, as 1784 made it.
It asks each government whether it is liable to observe the Proclamation as a duty imposed by law, and keeps every letter and answer in the Register, so that progress, or silence, is on the record.
Reconciliation on this view is not a new agreement but an old one honoured: the Crown’s attachment to its allies, kept.
What would each side do? The Crown would do what its own instruments provide: appoint the magistrates, take the oaths, and enter the names. It would not need a new statute to do so, on the Nation’s reading, because the Proclamation of 1796 has never been revoked.
The Nation, for its part, has begun without waiting. Its Register records lineage to the standard genealogists use, link by link, with each link marked documented or not. When the day comes that a magistrate asks who claims descent from the three villages, the proof will already be in order.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Duty imposed by law” means. Then read on.
Third parties, municipalities, registered owners, companies, would be asked for less than they may fear. The Nation does not seek to unseat private titles that do not conflict with the interest. It asks that the interest be observed: acknowledged on the record, and taken into account wherever a decision touches the Tract.
Compare this with the reconciliation that courts describe under section 35, which balances Aboriginal rights against the wider public interest through consultation and, where needed, justification. The Nation does not ask to be balanced. Its claim rests on a Crown grant carried into the Constitution by section 109 and guarded by section 52, and what such a grant asks for is performance.
Whether you are persuaded or not, notice the shape of the proposal. It can be tested. Each element points to a document and a date, and each can be met by a recorded act. A reconciliation that can be audited is rare; as you finish this course, write down what you would need to see on the record before you would call it done.
A sceptic may answer that two centuries of settlement cannot be reopened. The Nation’s reply is that it is not asking for the centuries to be undone. It asks for three recorded acts, each of which the Crown’s own instruments already provide for, and for the conversation that would follow them.
The source
All Lands, Mines, Minerals, and Royalties belonging to the several Provinces of Canada, Nova Scotia, and New Brunswick at the Union […] shall belong to the several Provinces of Ontario, Quebec, Nova Scotia, and New Brunswick in which the same are situate or arise, subject to any Trusts existing in respect thereof, and to any Interest other than that of the Province in the same.Constitution Act, 1867, s. 109 · 30 & 31 Vict, c 3 (UK).
Key terms
- Duty imposed by law
- An obligation the law itself places on an office.
- Record-keeping
- Here: finishing what the instruments provided for, and recording it.
- Performance
- Doing what was promised, as distinct from paying for not doing it.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Duty imposed by law, Record-keeping, Performance.