Courses · REC 101 Reconciliation: the Loyalist Mohawk history and law · Lesson 3 of 4
Where the record went quiet
Lecture 3 of 4 · about 6 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- What step does the Nation say was never performed?
- May band membership figures be cited as the posterity?
- What was the 1876 Indian Act’s frame?
The Nation holds that the 1796 ascertainment on oath before magistrates was never performed for the Mohawk class. Without it, the posterity was never confirmed or recorded by the Crown, and its number is still unknown.
The 1793 Patent, rejected, was treated later as if accepted. The 1876 Indian Act then defined people by status and band, a frame the class was never in.
So the Nation says band membership figures are never the posterity. The class was never counted; that is the gap.
Consider what each silence did. Because no magistrate took the oaths of the class, no list of the posterity was ever made by the Crown. When, generations later, courts and governments asked who held the grant, there was no Crown record to answer with, and the question was answered instead from the only lists that existed: those the Indian Department made for its own purposes.
Because the 1793 Patent was treated as accepted, the grant of 1784 was read through it. The Patent spoke of the Six Nations collectively and reserved the Crown’s protection. In Isaac v Davey the Supreme Court of Canada relied on it to hold that the Grand River lands were a reserve within the Indian Act. The Nation asks how an instrument recorded as refused came to govern those who refused it.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Posterity” means. Then read on.
Because the Indian Act of 1876 defined an “Indian” by band and by the male line, the hereditary class, which passes by either sex and has nothing to do with bands, had no place in the statute at all. A woman of the class who married out lost her status under the Act; under the 1789 Order she and her children lost nothing.
None of this required anyone to break a promise outright. It required only that a step be left undone and that later officials fill the gap with the tools they had. That is why the Nation speaks of a gap in the record and not only of a wrong: a gap can be closed.
It is also why the Nation insists on one rule of evidence in every discussion of numbers: band membership figures are never the posterity. The posterity has never been counted. To cite a band list as if it were the class is to repeat the substitution that caused the difficulty.
Historians call this an argument from silence, and it must be made with care: the absence of a record is evidence only where a record would be expected. Here the instrument itself required one, which is what gives the silence its weight.
The source
Whereas His Majesty having been pleased to direct that in consideration of the early attachment to his cause manifested by the Mohawk Indians, and of the loss of their settlement which they thereby sustained, that a convenient tract of land under his protection should be chosen as a safe and comfortable retreat for them and others of the Six Nations […] I do hereby in His Majesty’s name authorize and permit the said Mohawk Nation, and such others of the Six Nation Indians as wish to settle in that quarter, to take possession of and settle upon the banks of the river commonly called Ouse or Grand River, running into Lake Erie, allotting to them for that purpose six miles deep from each side of the river beginning at Lake Erie and extending in that proportion to the head of the said river, which them and their posterity are to enjoy for ever.The Haldimand Proclamation, 25 October 1784 (extract) · From the printed Crown text.
Key terms
- Posterity
- All descendants of the class, including the unborn.
- Gap in the record
- What an instrument provided for but was never done.
- Ascertainment
- Establishing on oath who belongs to a class.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Posterity, Gap in the record, Ascertainment.