Courses · REC 101 Reconciliation: the Loyalist Mohawk history and law · Lesson 1 of 4
Two relationships
Lecture 1 of 4 · about 6 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- Which relationship does the Pledge describe?
- On the Nation’s account, which Mohawk accepted the 1793 deed and protection?
- Where does reconciliation begin, in this course?
The Nation distinguishes two relationships with the Crown. Attachment is the Pledge’s word: allies who chose a side and kept to it. Protection is wardship: a people placed under the Crown’s care and management.
On the Nation’s account, the Bay of Quinte Mohawk accepted their 1793 deed and the Crown’s protection, and became an Indian Act band. The Grand River Mohawk rejected the Simcoe Patent and kept to attachment, and so have been treated since as if they did not exist.
Reconciliation begins by naming which relationship was promised. The Pledge promised the first.
The difference shows in the words each relationship uses. Allies make promises to one another and keep them; the word in the Pledge is ratify, the word a government uses for an agreement between powers. Wards are administered: lists are kept of them, agents are appointed over them, and their lands are held for them by someone else. Nothing in the Pledge speaks that second language.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Attachment” means. Then read on.
The Nation points to what the Mohawk of the three villages had done to earn the first. They had stood with the Crown from the Covenant Chain through the Revolution, and lost their homes for it. The Pledge does not offer them care. It acknowledges a debt, “the same should be restored at the expense of the Government”, and promises to pay it.
The two relationships lead to different law. Under protection, the Crown decides and then consults those affected. Under attachment, the Nation says, the Crown is bound by what it promised and must observe it: the question is not what the Crown now thinks best for a people in its care, but what it undertook to its allies. Courts have often reasoned from protection, as in Logan v Styres (1959), where the judge held that the Six Nations had become subjects by accepting the Crown’s protection. The Nation’s answer is that the Mohawk of the Grand River never accepted the instrument that would have made it so.
This course asks you to hold both relationships in view and to test, source by source, which one each document speaks. That is a historian’s task before it is a lawyer’s. Read the Pledge below slowly, and mark each word that belongs to an alliance and each that belongs to guardianship. Count them.
One caution. Naming the relationship does not settle every question between the Crown and the Nation. It settles which questions are the right ones to ask, and in what order, and it gives both sides a text they can point to.
The source
By His Excellency General Haldimand, Esq., Captain General and Commander-in-Chief of the Province of Quebec, and upon the frontiers of Quebec, etc. Some of the Mohawks of the Villages of Canojaharie, Tikondarago, and Aughugo, whose settlements than had been on account of their steady attachment to the King’s service and the interests of Government ruined by the rebels; having informed me that my predecessor, Sir Guy Carleton, was pleased to promise, as soon as the present troubles were at an end, the same should be restored at the expense of the Government, to the state they were in before the wars broke out, and said promise appearing to me just, I do hereby ratify the same and assure them the said promise, so far as in me lies, shall be faithfully executed, as soon as that happy time comes. GIVEN UNDER MY HAND AND SEAL at Quebec the 7th day of April, 1779. Signed: FRED HALDIMANDThe Haldimand Pledge, 7 April 1779 · Text as printed in secondary sources.
Key terms
- Attachment
- The relationship of allies, in the Pledge’s words.
- Protection
- Wardship: care and management by the Crown.
- Ratify
- To confirm a promise already made, with full force.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Attachment, Protection, Ratify.