Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Study · Courses · Reconciliation

REC 101

Reconciliation: the Loyalist Mohawk history and law

What the Crown promised the Loyalist Mohawk, what was kept and what was not, and what putting it right on the record would take.

4 lessons16 hours24 questions

Read the sample lesson Sample certificate Sample questions Enrol

The first lesson is open to everyone. The full course is $60, and free for members of the Nation. What it costs

$60for the whole course

Enrol in this courseRead lesson 1 freeFree for members of the Nation; anyone may ask for the fee to be waived. You enrol and pay in My Register. Withdraw within 14 days of paying and the fee is returned.

You will be able to

  • Identify the maker, date, addressee, purpose and kind of at least four of the course’s documents, and say how each has come down to us
  • Distinguish the words of a document from a reading of those words, quoting the passage relied on
  • Compare the Nation’s reading of the instruments with at least one other documented reading, stating each in its own terms
  • State the issue, the holding and its ground in Logan v. Styres and Davey v. Isaac, and what each left undecided
  • Assess an argument from a silent record: what was required, what record would be expected, and what has been searched
  • Produce a referenced evidence portfolio that makes a bounded claim, meets another reading and names what remains open

The course in a short lecture

The video has no sound and starts only when you press play. Turn on captions to read each slide’s text. It shows what you will be able to do and, for each lesson, a question, its illustration and a key term. Everything in it is also on the lesson pages.

Lessons

  1. 01Two relationshipsthe sample lesson · 6 questions · with a primary source
  2. 02Promises keptfor enrolled learners · with a primary source
  3. 03Where the record went quietfor enrolled learners · with a primary source
  4. 04Reconciling on the recordfor enrolled learners · with a primary source

How this course works

A complete course: an orientation, four lessons each in five parts, and an evidence portfolio. Every document and reading is linked in the lesson where it is used. The first lesson is open as the sample; the rest is for enrolled learners, in My Register.

  • Learn. The lesson, its terms and its figure.
  • Read or examine. The documents and the readings, with why each is there and what to read it for.
  • Work with the source. Questions answered by quoting the document.
  • Check your learning. Practice questions, marked in My Register with the reason for each answer.
  • Apply. A short note of your own. The four notes become the portfolio.

The hours, item by item

PartWhat it holdsTime
OrientationWhat the course is, how to read a source and a judgment, a first note40 min
Lesson 1Two relationships3 h 09 min
Lesson 2Promises kept2 h 50 min
Lesson 3Where the record went quiet3 h 30 min
Lesson 4Reconciling on the record2 h 50 min
The evidence portfolio800 to 1,000 words, or its equal in another form, such as a narrated presentation with its transcript.3 h
In allCounted item by item. A design figure: no learner has yet been timed.15 h 59 min

Other readings of the same record

This course gives the Nation’s reading and says so. A learner is also asked to state these accurately, each in its own terms. The Nation speaks for itself and for no one else.

Whose readingWhat it saysWhere
Ontario High Court, 1959The Six Nations who settled under the Crown’s protection owed it allegiance and became its subjects. The instrument of 1784 is a deed and not a treaty.Logan v. Styres
Ontario Court of Appeal, 1974The Proclamation and the Simcoe Deed had the same intention; the land is vested in the Crown; it is a reserve and the Six Nations a band. As Bourgeois reports it.Bourgeois (1986)
Supreme Court of Canada, 1977The Six Nations are a band because moneys are held for them by the Crown. Title was left undecided.Davey v. Isaac
Six Nations of the Grand River, in its actionThe Proclamation is a treaty that set the lands aside for the Six Nations and their descendants; the Crown failed to set them aside, sold most of them and mismanaged the proceeds.The litigation site
Canada and Ontario, in that actionThe Proclamation is not a treaty and created no duty to make a reserve; the surrenders and sales were valid.The litigation site
The Mohawks of the Bay of QuinteTheir deed of 1 April 1793 recognises their alliance with the Crown and their losses; it speaks of “Our protection”.Their account
HistoriansJohnston: Brant rejected the Patent because disposing of land would hang on an offer to the Crown. Graymont: Brant held the land should be theirs in fee simple. Filice: the grant was to the Haudenosaunee, and Brant saw the Patent as reinforcing the Crown’s “trusteeship interpretation of the title”.Graymont · Filice

Activities

Young learnersDraw two friends keeping a promise.
Middle schoolSort events into “promise kept” and “not yet”.
UniversityEssay: reconciliation as record-keeping.
Law schoolMoot: duty to observe against duty to consult.

Official description and materials

1.5 University credits · 16 learner hours, counted item by item. The credit is the University’s own unit, proposed and not yet adopted. It is not the credit of any other institution; a receiving institution decides what it recognises. How credits work →

Read further

  • Alan Taylor, The Divided Ground (Knopf, 2006)
  • Rick Monture, We Share Our Matters (University of Manitoba Press, 2014)
  • Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada, Calls to Action (2015)

At four levels

Undergraduate and up

  • Attachment and protection as two relationships
  • The ascertainment never performed
  • Reconciliation as record-keeping

Standards

This course follows the University’s standards (set one): a Master Content Card, the universal competencies and a curriculum map. How the standards work →

Essential questions, rising in demand

  1. What did the Crown promise the Loyalist Mohawk?
  2. How do attachment and protection differ?
  3. Evaluate reconciliation as finishing the instruments’ work.

Claims and who contests them

  • Claim. The Pledge promised attachment, not protection. Contested by: Crown practice since 1876 has treated the Mohawk under protection (the Indian Act).
  • Claim. The 1796 ascertainment was never performed for the class. Contested by: Not yet answered by the Crown on the record.

Curriculum map

LevelOntario and CanadaInternational level
Young learnersOntario: Social Studies Gr 3, Strand A: Communities in Canada, 1780–1850ISCED 1 (primary)
Middle schoolOntario: Gr 7 History, Strands A and B; Gr 8 History, Strand A; historical thinking (historical significance · cause and consequence · continuity and change · historical perspective)ISCED 2 (lower secondary)
SecondaryOntario: NAC2O First Nations, Métis, and Inuit in Canada (Gr 10); CLU3M (Gr 11); CHI4U (Gr 12)ISCED 3 (upper secondary)
UniversityOntario Undergraduate Degree Level Expectations; CMEC Canadian Degree Qualifications FrameworkISCED 6 (bachelor’s)
Law schoolFLSC National Requirement; TRC Call to Action 28ISCED 7 (professional, J.D.)

National: TRC Calls to Action 62–63 and 28; UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act, S.C. 2021, c. 14. Global: UNDRIP arts. 14–15 and 26; UN SDG 4, target 4.7.