Courses · REC 101 Reconciliation: the Loyalist Mohawk history and law · Orientation
Orientation · about 40 min
Before you begin
What this course is, whose account it gives, and how to read a source and a judgment.
What this course is
This course studies one record: four instruments of the Crown, of 1779, 1784, 1789 and 1796; a fifth, the Patent of 1793, which the Nation sets aside; a Wampum belt of 1815; and what courts and statutes later made of them.
It is taught by Mohawk University, the place of study of the Mohawk Nation of Grand River, and it gives the Nation’s reading of that record. It says so each time: “the Nation reads”, “on the Nation’s account”.
The Nation speaks for itself. It does not speak for the Haudenosaunee Confederacy, for the elected council of Six Nations of the Grand River, for the Mississaugas of the Credit, or for other Mohawk communities. Each has its own account. Where this course cites one, it cites their own words.
What it asks of you
Read the documents themselves. Tell three things apart: a document’s words, a reading of those words, and a court’s holding. State a reading you do not share so that its holders would accept your statement of it.
You do not have to agree with the Nation, or with anyone. You are marked on how you use the evidence.
What it does not do
It gives no legal advice, and it decides no case. The Proclamation of 1784 is before the Ontario Superior Court of Justice now, in an action brought by Six Nations of the Grand River against Canada and Ontario. Nothing here settles what that court will decide.
It speaks of land, law and loss. No one is asked to disclose anything personal, or to speak for a community.
Six questions for any source
Who made it, and when? For whom, and for what purpose? Is this the original, a registered copy, a printing, a transcription or a later summary? What does it directly say? What is being inferred from it? What is missing, and whose knowledge would be needed to fill it?
Three labels, with one example
Words. The Pledge of 1779 speaks of “their steady attachment to the King’s service”. Cite it as: Haldimand’s Pledge, 7 April 1779, as printed in secondary sources citing the Haldimand Papers (Public Archives of Canada, A-683).
Reading. The Nation reads those words as naming a relationship of allies. Cite it as the Nation’s reading, with the lesson.
Holding. In Logan v. Styres the Ontario High Court held that the Six Nations who settled under the Crown’s protection became its subjects. Cite it as: Logan v. Styres (1959), 20 D.L.R. (2d) 416 (Ont. H.C.).
Written work is cited in Chicago notes and bibliography.
How to read a judgment
Ask four things. What was the issue the court had to decide? What did it hold? On what ground? What did it leave undecided? Then ask which court it was, and what happened on appeal: a holding of a lower court may be narrowed or set aside by a higher one.
Your own words
Written work is your own. No AI tool writes or rewrites any part of it. A learner who has finished FAC 105, the University’s course on the ethical use of AI, may use such a tool only where the instructor of this course allows it, and says what it was used for when handing the piece in. The University runs no program that claims to tell whether a person or a machine wrote the words; it relies on your declaration and on your instructor’s reading.
How the course runs
Each of the four lessons has five parts. Learn: the lesson and its terms. Read or examine: the documents and readings, each linked where it is used, with a line on why it is there and what to read it for. Work with the source: questions you answer by quoting. Check your learning: practice questions, marked in My Register. Apply: a short note of your own.
The four notes become your evidence portfolio, which closes the course.
Who and what you will meet
No lesson uses a name before it is introduced. Each lesson opens with those it brings in; here they are together.
People
- Sir Guy Carleton, later Lord Dorchester
- Governor of Quebec when the American Revolution began. He made the first promise to the Mohawk. He came back in 1786 as Lord Dorchester, Governor-in-Chief, and in 1789 made the Order that created the Mark of Honour. Carleton and Dorchester are one man.
- Sir Frederick Haldimand
- Carleton’s successor as Governor of Quebec, from 1778. He ratified the promise in 1779, which is the Pledge, and made the Proclamation of 1784.
- John Graves Simcoe
- The first Lieutenant Governor of Upper Canada, from 1791 to 1796. The Patent of 1793 and the Proclamation of 1796 are his.
- Joseph Brant, Thayendanegea
- A Mohawk of Canajoharie, a war leader, and the Mohawk’s chief spokesman with the Crown. He led the move to the Grand River, and he refused Simcoe’s Patent.
- John Deserontyon
- Leader of the Mohawk of Fort Hunter, who chose to settle at the Bay of Quinte and not on the Grand River.
- William Claus
- Deputy Superintendent General of Indian Affairs in the War of 1812. He gave the belt of 1815.
Peoples and bodies
- The Mohawk of the three villages
- Canajoharie, Tikondarago and Aughquaga, in and near the Mohawk Valley, in what is now New York State. The Pledge is addressed to “some of the Mohawks” of these villages, who kept to the King’s side in the American Revolution and lost their homes for it.
- The Six Nations
- The Mohawk, Oneida, Onondaga, Cayuga and Seneca, the Five Nations of the Haudenosaunee Confederacy, joined in the 1720s by the Tuscarora. The Mohawk are one of the six.
- The Mohawk Nation of Grand River
- Whose course this is. It holds that the grant of 1784 was made to the Mohawk named in the Pledge and their descendants, and it keeps its own Register. It is not the band, and it does not speak for the Confederacy.
- Six Nations of the Grand River
- The community on the Grand River today and, in Canadian law, a band under the Indian Act, governed since 1924 by an elected council at Ohsweken. It is the plaintiff in the action now before the court against Canada and Ontario.
- The Confederacy chiefs
- The council of hereditary chiefs of the Six Nations, removed from the Council House at Ohsweken in 1924. The two court cases in this course arose between its supporters and the elected council.
- The Mississaugas
- The people from whom the Crown bought the land between Lakes Ontario, Erie and Huron in 1784. Today, the Mississaugas of the Credit First Nation.
- The Mohawks of the Bay of Quinte
- The Mohawk who settled on Lake Ontario, under their own deed of 1 April 1793. Today, at Tyendinaga.
- The Loyalists
- Those in the American colonies who kept to the Crown in the American Revolution, from 1775 to 1783. The Treaty of Paris of 1783, which the documents call the Treaty of Separation, ended that war.
- The Crown
- The King or Queen, in whose name governors acted. Since 1867 the Crown acts in right of Canada and in right of each province; here, Ontario.
- The courts
- The High Court of Justice of Ontario tried cases. The Court of Appeal for Ontario heard appeals from it. The Supreme Court of Canada is the last court of appeal. A judge is cited by name and the letter J., as in King J.
Places
- The Province of Quebec, and Upper Canada
- In 1779 and 1784 the country from the St Lawrence to the Great Lakes was the Province of Quebec. In 1791 it was divided, and its western part became Upper Canada, which is now Ontario.
- The Grand River, and the Tract
- The river runs into Lake Erie. The Proclamation’s lands are six miles deep from each side of it, from the lake to its head. The Nation calls them the Tract.
- Burlington Heights
- High ground at the head of Lake Ontario, now in Hamilton, where the council of 1815 was held.
Terms the Nation uses
- The instruments
- The four documents of the Crown this course studies: the Pledge of 1779, the Proclamation of 1784, the Order in Council of 1789 and the Proclamation of 1796.
- The class, and the posterity
- The class is the Mohawk of the three villages named in the Pledge. The posterity is their descendants, born and unborn.
- Attachment and protection
- Attachment is the bond of allies, in the Pledge’s word. Protection, as the courts have read it, is wardship. Lesson 1 sets the two side by side.
- The Mark of Honour
- The letters U.E., for Unity of the Empire, which the Order of 1789 puts after the names of Loyalists and their descendants.
- The Covenant Chain
- The alliance between the Crown and the Five Nations, begun in the seventeenth century and spoken of as a silver chain that each side keeps bright.
- A Wampum belt
- A belt of shell beads that carries the memory of an agreement or a message. It is given when words are meant to be kept.
- The Register
- The Nation’s own book of record, where lineage is recorded and the Nation’s letters and their answers are kept.
A first note
Before you begin, write a few lines for yourself. It is not marked. What can a document establish, and what can it leave unknown? Keep it, and read it again when you finish the portfolio.