Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · SET 101 Introduction to Settler Studies · Lesson 6 of 6

If the law prevailed

Lecture 6 of 6 · about 7 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. In the model, what would a parcel register on the Tract carry?
  2. What would happen to private owners whose titles do not conflict with the interest?
  3. What is the standing of this model?

This lesson is a thought experiment, and it is meant seriously. Suppose that every office with a hand in the Grand River valley applied the Crown’s instruments as they are written and the Constitution as the supreme law. What would change, and what would stay the same? What follows is the Nation’s model. It is not the law as the courts have declared it, and the lesson ends with what is contested.

First, the interest would be on the record. The register for every parcel on the Tract would carry a note of the interest of 1784, as it carries any earlier interest that binds the land. The curtain would no longer hide it. A buyer, a lender and a municipality would each see it as a matter of course.

Second, the class would be ascertained. In 1796 Simcoe’s proclamation provided for those entitled to be recorded on oath before magistrates. The Nation holds that this was never done for the Mohawk class. If the law prevailed it would be done, and the Crown’s roll and the Nation’s Register would agree on who the posterity are. Membership of the class would rest on a proved line to one of the three villages, and not on a department’s list.

Third, offices would act subject to the interest. The Province holds its lands under section 109 “subject to” other interests. A ministry or a municipality acting on the Tract would therefore ask, before it acted, whether the act was consistent with the interest of 1784, as it already asks whether an act is consistent with the Charter. Where a statute and the Constitution could not both stand, section 52 would give the answer.

Fourth, there would be an account. Rents, royalties and a share of the taxes raised on the Tract would be reckoned and paid to those entitled. The lost investments would be entered and answered for. An account is ordinary law between any owner and anyone who has had the use of what is theirs.

The picture compares the Tract as it is with the Nation’s model of it. Read across in pairs: each line on the left has its answer on the right.
As it isThe interest of 1784 is not on any parcelregisterA band list stands in for the classOffices act without askingNo account is keptIf the law prevailedEvery parcel register notes the interestThe class is ascertained on oath, as 1796providedOffices act subject to the interestRents and taxes are reckoned and paid

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Subject to” means. Then read on.

Fifth, relations would run from the Nation to the Crown. The Nation would deal directly with the King’s representatives, as allies did in 1784. It does not dispute the King’s sovereignty in Canadian society. Its own order would run over its own territory and its own people, alongside the Crown’s and not against it.

It matters as much to say what would not happen. Nobody would be put out of a house. The Nation does not seek to unseat private titles that do not conflict with the interest. The question for a householder in Brantford would be to whom certain payments are due. The home would be undisturbed. The Tract would not become a reserve, and the land would not be held in trust, because both of those belong to wardship. And no new treaty would be needed, because the instruments already exist.

The institutions on the Tract would find their part easily. A university that acknowledges where it stands would recognise the class the instruments name, on the Nation’s Register and the Crown’s roll together. It would share its courses, and it would treat tuition for that class as a small part of an account already owed.

Now the contest. The Crown in right of Canada and of Ontario has not accepted this reading, and no court has ordered it. Others at the Grand River hold different views of whose the Tract is and who speaks for it. Private owners rely on a register that the Province guarantees. A student’s task is to state the model exactly, to state the strongest objection to each of its parts, and to say what evidence would settle the matter. Then draft one page: the entry you would write on a single parcel register, if the law prevailed.

The source

The Constitution of Canada is the supreme law of Canada, and any law that is inconsistent with the provisions of the Constitution is, to the extent of the inconsistency, of no force or effect. … All Lands, Mines, Minerals, and Royalties belonging to the several Provinces of Canada, Nova Scotia, and New Brunswick at the Union […] shall belong to the several Provinces of Ontario, Quebec, Nova Scotia, and New Brunswick in which the same are situate or arise, subject to any Trusts existing in respect thereof, and to any Interest other than that of the Province in the same.
Constitution Act, 1982, section 52(1), read with the Constitution Act, 1867, section 109 · Schedule B to the Canada Act 1982 (UK), 1982, c. 11; 30 & 31 Vict., c. 3 (UK).

Key terms

Ascertainment
Establishing on oath, before a magistrate, who belongs to the class an instrument names.
Subject to
Words in section 109 that make the Province’s ownership give way to earlier interests.
Account
A reckoning of what one party owes another for the use of what is theirs.
Supremacy
The rule in section 52 that a law inconsistent with the Constitution is of no force or effect.

Check yourself

1.In the model, what would a parcel register on the Tract carry?
2.What would happen to private owners whose titles do not conflict with the interest?
3.What is the standing of this model?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Ascertainment, Subject to, Account, Supremacy.