Courses · SET 101 Introduction to Settler Studies · Lesson 4 of 6
Contemporary settler issues
Lecture 4 of 6 · about 7 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- On the Nation’s reading, what kind of interest did the 1784 Proclamation give?
- Which move puts a band list where the class should be?
- Is the Nation’s reading accepted by Canada and Ontario?
Indigenous Studies calendars list “contemporary issues”. So does this one, and the issue is this: how do the tools of the last lesson go on working today, on land that the Crown itself granted and that the Constitution protects? The answer needs the Nation’s position stated first, and stated as the Nation’s.
On 25 October 1784 Governor Haldimand, in the King’s name, authorised the Mohawk Nation, and such others of the Six Nations as wished to settle there, to take possession of the land six miles deep on each side of the Grand River, from Lake Erie to its head, “which them and their posterity are to enjoy for ever”. The Nation reads this as a Crown instrument that gives exclusive use and enjoyment. Because it is the Crown’s own act, the Nation holds that the interest is Crown-derived. It is not an Aboriginal right to be proved under section 35, and the land is not held in trust for a band.
Two sections of the Constitution carry that interest forward. Section 109 of the Constitution Act, 1867 gave the Province its lands “subject to any Trusts existing in respect thereof, and to any Interest other than that of the Province in the same”. The Nation holds that the interest of 1784 is such an interest, so that what Ontario received on the Tract it received subject to it. Section 52 of the Constitution Act, 1982 makes the Constitution the supreme law, and any law inconsistent with it of no force or effect.
Now watch the tools at work. They make four moves, and each can be seen on the Tract today.
The first move is reclassification. A thing is given a new name and then treated according to the name. The grant of 1784 was read through the Simcoe Patent of 1793, which the Mohawk of the Grand River did not accept. In time the land was called a “reserve”, and in 1977 the Supreme Court of Canada, in Isaac v. Davey, relied on the Patent to hold that it was one within the meaning of the Indian Act. An ally became a ward by a change of words.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Exclusive use and enjoyment” means. Then read on.
The second move is substitution. The class to whom the promise was made is replaced by a list that a department keeps. The Pledge of 1779 named “some of the Mohawks” of three villages, and the Proclamation their posterity. The Indian Act put in their place a band and its membership list. When an institution on the Tract now wishes to honour the Proclamation, it asks for a status card. The University of Waterloo, whose main campus stands on the Tract by its own acknowledgement, has since 2023 waived tuition for members of the Six Nations of the Grand River. That was done in good faith. It also shows the substitution exactly: the list stands where the class should be.
The third move is silence in the register. Open the parcel register for any lot in Brantford, Kitchener or Caledonia and you will find no entry for the interest of 1784. The curtain is drawn, and behind it the interest goes unseen by every buyer, lender and lawyer who relies on the register.
The fourth move is jurisdiction by habit. Provincial and municipal offices act on the Tract as they act anywhere, issuing permits, tickets and tax bills, because nothing in their daily procedure tells them to ask whether a prior interest stands in the way. The officer does not decide against the Proclamation. The officer has never been asked to think of it.
None of this is settled. Canada and Ontario do not accept the Nation’s reading. A claim about the Tract, begun in 1995 by the elected council of the Six Nations, is before the Ontario Superior Court. And the Nation’s own position differs from that claim, since it rests on the Crown’s instruments and the class they name. A student should be able to state each position fairly before choosing among them.
The source
Whereas His Majesty having been pleased to direct that in consideration of the early attachment to his cause manifested by the Mohawk Indians, and of the loss of their settlement which they thereby sustained, that a convenient tract of land under his protection should be chosen as a safe and comfortable retreat for them and others of the Six Nations […] I do hereby in His Majesty’s name authorize and permit the said Mohawk Nation, and such others of the Six Nation Indians as wish to settle in that quarter, to take possession of and settle upon the banks of the river commonly called Ouse or Grand River, running into Lake Erie, allotting to them for that purpose six miles deep from each side of the river beginning at Lake Erie and extending in that proportion to the head of the said river, which them and their posterity are to enjoy for ever.The Haldimand Proclamation, 25 October 1784 · Given at Quebec; signed Fred. Haldimand.
Key terms
- Exclusive use and enjoyment
- The right to have and use land to the exclusion of others; the Nation’s reading of what the 1784 Proclamation gives.
- Crown-derived interest
- An interest that comes from the Crown’s own grant, as distinct from an Aboriginal right.
- Reclassification
- Giving a thing a new legal name and then treating it by the name.
- Substitution
- Putting a department’s list in the place of the class an instrument names.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Exclusive use and enjoyment, Crown-derived interest, Reclassification, Substitution.