Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · SET 101 Introduction to Settler Studies · Lesson 5 of 6

Attachments and enrichments

Lecture 5 of 6 · about 7 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. Whose word is “attachment”?
  2. What are the three questions of unjust enrichment?
  3. Why not net one column against the other?

A course that stopped at the last lesson would be a list of grievances, and it would be false, because it would leave out half of what happened. The Mohawk of the Grand River were never only acted upon. They chose an alliance, kept it at great cost, and took from the newcomers what they judged worth having. This lesson draws up the account on both sides.

Begin with attachments, and with the word itself, which is the Crown’s. The Proclamation of 1784 speaks of “the early attachment to his cause manifested by the Mohawk Indians”. An attachment is a bond that is chosen. The record of this one is long. In 1710 four leaders crossed the ocean and were received by Queen Anne. In 1712 she sent a set of communion silver for her chapel among the Mohawk, and it came with them to the Grand River. The Book of Common Prayer was printed in Mohawk in 1715, and again in London in 1787 with the Gospel of Mark translated by Joseph Brant. The Chapel at the Grand River was built in 1785, and it is a Chapel Royal still. In 1789 the Crown gave the Loyalists and their descendants the Mark of Honour, the letters U.E. In 1869 the Mohawk made Prince Arthur a chief.

Two things should be said about these attachments. They are between the Mohawk and the Crown: the King, and not the colony or its legislature. And an attachment is not a submission. A people may be attached to the Crown and oppose what colonial offices do in the Crown’s name. The Nation’s whole case depends on that distinction, because the instruments it relies on are the Crown’s own.

Now enrichments, which run both ways. From the newcomers the Mohawk took writing and print, and made their language one of the first on the continent with its own printed books. They took silver, cloth and glass beads and made of them arts that are recognisably theirs. They took the plough, the mill and the school. Brant asked for a schoolmaster and a mill among the first things at the Grand River. And they gained a body of written instruments in the Crown’s own hand, which their descendants can read and hold the Crown to.

The picture is an account in two columns. Read down the left for what the Mohawk took from the newcomers and made their own, and down the right for what the colony gained. The columns are not added together: each entry stands.
To the MohawkWriting and print in the languageSilver, cloth and beads, made into theirown artsThe plough, the mill, the school they askedforThe Crown’s instruments, in writingTo the colonyNearly a million acres of the valleyCities, farms, roads and universities on itSix Nations funds put into the NavigationCompanyRents, sale prices and taxes, every year

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Attachment” means. Then read on.

The enrichment of the colony is larger and can be measured. It begins with the land: nearly a million acres along one of the most fertile valleys in the province. On it now stand cities, farms, highways, factories and universities. It includes money. From 1834 the Crown’s officers put Six Nations funds, without the people’s consent, into the Grand River Navigation Company. The company failed and the money was lost. And it continues each year in rents, sale prices and municipal taxes paid for land on the Tract to someone other than those to whom it was granted.

The law has a tool for a state of affairs like this. A claim in unjust enrichment asks three questions, which the Supreme Court of Canada restated in 2004: was the defendant enriched; did the plaintiff suffer a corresponding deprivation; and is there no juristic reason, such as a contract or a gift, for the enrichment? Use the three questions here as a way of thinking, and not as a verdict. Applied to one parcel, they make a student find out who holds it, how they came to hold it, and what was paid to whom.

Keep the two columns honestly. Enter each item with its date and its source. Do not set one column against the other to reach a single figure: a gift received does not cancel a taking, and a taking does not turn a gift into a trick. Communion silver and a lost investment are both true, and a fair account shows both.

The source

Indigenous peoples have the right to redress, by means that can include restitution or, when this is not possible, just, fair and equitable compensation, for the lands, territories and resources which they have traditionally owned or otherwise occupied or used, and which have been confiscated, taken, occupied, used or damaged without their free, prior and informed consent.
United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, article 28(1) · UN General Assembly resolution 61/295, 13 September 2007.

Key terms

Attachment
A chosen bond between parties who each stand on their own feet; the Crown’s word in 1784.
Enrichment
A benefit gained; in law, the first element of a claim in unjust enrichment.
Juristic reason
A legal ground, such as a contract or a gift, that justifies a benefit being kept.
Mark of Honour
The letters U.E., given by the Crown in 1789 to the Loyalists and their descendants.

Check yourself

1.Whose word is “attachment”?
2.What are the three questions of unjust enrichment?
3.Why not net one column against the other?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Attachment, Enrichment, Juristic reason, Mark of Honour.