Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · SET 101 Introduction to Settler Studies · Lesson 3 of 6

Settler governance

Lecture 3 of 6 · about 7 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. What does a survey do?
  2. What does the curtain principle do to an interest never entered in the register?
  3. What do the six tools have in common?

Ideas do not move a boundary. Paper does. This lesson is about the instruments of colonial government, taken in the order in which a piece of land meets them. A student who can explain how each one works understands colonialism better than one who can only condemn it.

The first tool is the survey. A surveyor walks the land with a chain and compass and lays over it a grid of townships, concessions and lots. Before the survey there is a river, a forest and the people who live there. After it there are numbered rectangles that can be described in a sentence and sold to someone who has never seen them. The survey takes nothing by itself, but everything afterwards depends on it.

The second is the patent. The Crown grants a lot to a named person, usually on conditions: clear so many acres, build a house, open the road in front. The patent is the root of a private title. Every deed since traces back to it.

The third is the registry. Deeds are copied into a public office so that a buyer can see who owns what. Ontario later adopted the land titles system, built on three principles that lawyers call the mirror, the curtain and the guarantee. The register is taken to mirror the true state of the title. A curtain is drawn across everything behind it, so that a buyer need look no further. And the government guarantees what the register shows. This is a fine system for buyers and lenders. Consider, though, what it does to an interest that was never entered. Behind the curtain, for practical purposes, it ceases to be seen.

The fourth is the statute. A legislature in which the nations had no seat passed laws about them. The Indian Act of 1876 drew together earlier acts and defined who was an “Indian”, what a “band” and a “reserve” were, and who would manage their land and money. Its definition of “person”, printed below, tells you how its authors saw the matter. The band list followed from the Act: a register kept by a department, deciding who belonged.

The picture follows one piece of land through four offices. Read it from left to right: each box is a tool, and beneath its name is what the land has become when that office has done its work.
The surveyA river and a forestbecome numbered lotsThe patentA lot becomes oneperson’s propertyThe registryThe title becomesall a buyer need seeThe statute andthe townPeople are listed;the land is taxedand zoned

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Survey” means. Then read on.

The fifth is the municipality. Counties, townships, towns and cities were incorporated across the land, with power to tax, to zone, to build roads and to pass by-laws. A municipality is the form of government a resident meets most often, and it is the one that most takes its own authority for granted.

The sixth is the school. The Mohawk Institute at Brantford opened as a day school in 1828, took boarders from 1831 and did not close until 1970. Its purpose was to carry the worldview of the last lesson into the next generation: English in place of Kanien’kéha, the trades and the farm in place of what the children’s families would have taught them.

Put the six in a row and a pattern appears. None of them requires force at the moment it is used. A surveyor, a clerk, a registrar, a legislator, a reeve and a teacher each does an ordinary day’s work, each in good order and by the rules of the office. The result, added up over a century, is that a people’s land and affairs are in other hands. This is what Wolfe meant by a structure.

Notice also that every one of these tools is a record. That is why the Nation answers with records of its own. A Register, a Gazette, a Ledger and a map are the same kind of instrument, turned to the other purpose.

The source

The term “person” means an individual other than an Indian, unless the context clearly requires another construction.
The Indian Act, 1876, section 3(12) · S.C. 1876, c. 18. The definition stood until 1951.

Key terms

Survey
The measuring of land into numbered lots that can be described and sold.
Patent
The Crown’s grant of a lot to a named person; the root of a private title.
Curtain principle
In land titles, the rule that a buyer need not look behind the register.
Band list
A department’s register of who belongs to a band under the Indian Act.

Check yourself

1.What does a survey do?
2.What does the curtain principle do to an interest never entered in the register?
3.What do the six tools have in common?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Survey, Patent, Curtain principle, Band list.