Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · SET 101 Introduction to Settler Studies · Lesson 2 of 6

Settler worldviews

Lecture 2 of 6 · about 7 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. What did Locke’s idea of improvement make of land held in common?
  2. What do the five ideas have in common?
  3. What word did the 1784 Proclamation use for the Mohawk’s relationship to the Crown?

An Indigenous Studies course has a unit on worldviews. So has this one. People do not take a continent without ideas that make the taking seem right, and the ideas the settlers carried can be named, dated and read in their own words. Here are five.

The first is discovery. In 1493 a papal bull divided the newly reached lands between Spain and Portugal, and European powers afterwards agreed among themselves that the first Christian nation to arrive gained a right over the land against all the others. In 1823 the Supreme Court of the United States made this a rule of law in Johnson v. M’Intosh, and in 1888 the Privy Council, in St. Catherine’s Milling, described the Indian interest in land as “a personal and usufructuary right, dependent upon the good will of the Sovereign”. The Vatican formally repudiated the doctrine in 2023.

The second is improvement. John Locke wrote in 1689 that a man makes land his own by mixing his labour with it: by enclosing, clearing and planting. On that view, land that is hunted over or farmed in common is “waste”, waiting for an owner. The idea is written into the patents of Upper Canada, which required a settler to clear a set number of acres and build a house before the land was his.

The third is the ladder of civilisation. Scottish thinkers of the eighteenth century arranged all societies in stages: hunters, then herders, then farmers, then merchants. Every people was assumed to be climbing the same ladder, with Britain at the top. From this came the belief that to change another people’s way of life was a kindness.

The table sets out five ideas. Read across each row: the idea, what it says, and what it did on this side of the ocean.
The ideaWhat it saysWhat it did hereDiscoveryThe first Christian power toarrive gains a rightTitle was said to lie with theCrownImprovementLand belongs to whoever clearsand plants itPatents required clearing and ahouseThe ladderAll peoples climb the samestagesChanging a way of life wascalled a kindnessProtectionThe higher guards the lowerAllies were treated as wardsDisappearanceThe first peoples will vanishThe 1857 Act offered“enfranchisement”

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Improvement” means. Then read on.

The fourth is protection. If a people stands lower on the ladder, the higher has a duty to guard it as a parent guards a child. The Royal Proclamation spoke of nations “who live under our Protection”. By the nineteenth century the word had hardened into wardship: the Indian as a legal minor and the Crown as guardian of his land and money.

The fifth is disappearance. Settlers expected that the first peoples would vanish, by death or by absorption, and they made policy for an ending. The Act of 1857, printed below, speaks of “the gradual removal of all legal distinctions”. A person who qualified could be “enfranchised”: he gained the vote and a lot of land, and ceased in law to be an Indian. The policy assumed that anyone would want this. In nearly twenty years, only one man took it up.

Notice what the five have in common. Each explains to the settler why the land should be his, and each presents the taking as a benefit to the people it was taken from. None was held in bad faith by most of those who held it. That is the reason to study it: a worldview is invisible to the person who lives inside it.

These ideas met a difficulty on the Grand River, and the next lessons follow it. The Mohawk were allies and not wards. Their land was a grant in the King’s name and not “waste”. In the 1784 Proclamation the Crown used a different word for the relationship. It spoke of the Mohawk’s “early attachment to his cause”. Attachment is a bond between parties who each stand on their own feet. Protection is the care of a ward. Much of what followed can be read as the colony’s effort to turn the first relationship into the second.

The source

Whereas it is desirable to encourage the progress of Civilization among the Indian Tribes in this Province, and the gradual removal of all legal distinctions between them and Her Majesty’s other Canadian Subjects, and to facilitate the acquisition of property and of the rights accompanying it, by such Individual Members of the said Tribes as shall be found to desire such encouragement and to have deserved it.
An Act to encourage the gradual Civilization of the Indian Tribes in this Province, 1857: the preamble · Statutes of the Province of Canada, 20 Vict., c. 26.

Key terms

Doctrine of discovery
The claim that the first Christian power to reach a land gained a right over it against other powers.
Improvement
The idea that land belongs to whoever encloses and cultivates it.
Wardship
Treating a people as legal minors, with the Crown as guardian.
Enfranchisement
Ceasing in law to be an Indian in exchange for the vote and a lot of land.

Check yourself

1.What did Locke’s idea of improvement make of land held in common?
2.What do the five ideas have in common?
3.What word did the 1784 Proclamation use for the Mohawk’s relationship to the Crown?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Doctrine of discovery, Improvement, Wardship, Enfranchisement.