Courses · PUB 102 Reporting, editing and media law · Lesson 5 of 5
The Online News Act and the Nation’s press
Lecture 5 of 5 · about 10 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- What did Meta do in answer to the Online News Act?
- Who decides whether an outlet is an “eligible news business” under the Act?
- What does the Nation hold about such a statute on the Tract?
The first four lessons taught what a newsroom does. This one teaches what is done to it. A press on the Grand River works under rules it did not make: Canada’s statutes on news, broadcasting and advertising, and the decisions of the companies that carry its words to readers. The clearest recent case is the Online News Act.
Parliament passed the Act in June 2023. Its stated purpose is fairness in the digital news marketplace and the sustainability of news businesses. It applies to large online platforms, a search engine or a social media service, that make news available to people in Canada and hold a strong bargaining position over news businesses. Such a platform must bargain with eligible news businesses and pay them, or win an exemption by making agreements that meet a list of conditions. Canada’s broadcasting regulator, the CRTC, administers it.
What followed shows how a law can hurt those it was written to help. Google agreed to pay one hundred million dollars a year, indexed, to a collective that shares it among news businesses. Meta, which owns Facebook and Instagram, took another course. From August 2023 it stopped showing news to people in Canada at all, and links from news outlets can no longer be seen or shared there. Researchers at McGill University found a year later that Canadian outlets had lost 85 per cent of their engagement on the two services, that 212 local outlets had gone silent on social media, and that only about one Canadian in five knew of the block. As this lesson is written, in November 2026, the block is still in place. Talks between Canada and Meta have been reported, and no result has been announced.
Indigenous media felt it more than most, because in many communities Facebook was where news travelled. The publisher of Turtle Island News, at Six Nations of the Grand River, told the CBC that the paper had lost advertising, could no longer use the service for breaking news, and did not know how a community was to be warned in an emergency. The Mohawk newspaper Iorì:wase, at Kahnawake, reported a fall in readers. IndigiNews, in British Columbia, said that 43 per cent of its audience could no longer reach its stories. Eagle Feather News, in Saskatchewan, announced a pause in publication in early 2024, its editor saying that advertising had collapsed after the block.
The Act does name Indigenous news outlets. Its definition is printed below. It makes such an outlet eligible to be paid if it covers matters of general interest, including the rights of Indigenous peoples, and it asks that a platform’s agreements benefit a significant portion of them. Notice who decides each of those things. The definition is Parliament’s. An outlet becomes eligible by order of the CRTC, on its own application. And “Indigenous peoples” takes its meaning from section 35 of the Constitution Act, 1982.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Eligible news business” means. Then read on.
Here the Nation’s position parts from Canada’s, and this University teaches it as the Nation’s. The Nation holds that the Tract is acquired territory, set apart by the Crown in 1784 for the exclusive use and enjoyment of the Mohawk class and its posterity, on a footing that is Crown-derived and is not a section 35 right. On that reading, a statute of Canada that decides which of the Nation’s publishers is a news business, through which Canadian body it must apply, and on what terms its words may travel, reaches into that territory and assumes an authority over it. The Nation calls that an encroachment, and an assertion of a claim to its territory. It holds that section 52 prevails: a statute gives way to the extent that it is inconsistent. And it adds a practical point. A press that loses its readers when another government quarrels with a company has been frozen by a dispute in which it had no voice.
Canada does not accept that reading. Its ministers have said that the Act asks large platforms to pay a fair share for the news they profit from, and that the block was Meta’s own choice. On its face the Act places its duties on platforms, and a news business comes under it only by applying. Meta’s position is that news has little value to its business and that it will not pay for links which people and publishers choose to post. Many publishers support the Act and blame the company. Others, among them small and Indigenous outlets, have said that the Act was written with large newsrooms in mind and that they bear its cost. No court has ruled on the Nation’s reading. A learner should be able to state each of these positions so that its holder would accept the statement.
The Act does not stand alone. In July 2023 the federal government stopped buying advertising on Facebook and Instagram in answer to the block, and papers that had sold advertising on the strength of their reach there found the advertising gone with the readers. Canada’s tax credit for journalism goes to organisations designated under its Income Tax Act. Its Broadcasting Act, amended in 2023 to reach online streaming, sets the rules for the air and for large online services, and the Nation’s book on its Station says that if the Station ever takes an over-the-air frequency it will do so under the rules that govern that frequency. Since 2024 the CRTC has said that it is developing a new Indigenous broadcasting policy together with Indigenous peoples. In each case a body of another government decides who counts as media.
What can a press of record do meanwhile? Four things, and none of them waits on anyone’s leave. Own the road to your readers: print, the paper’s own website, and a mailing list that readers have chosen. PUB 101’s channels are built this way, and the Nation’s letters go only to readers who have confirmed that they want them. Keep the record: date and keep every instance in which a law or a company stopped the paper’s words, since a grievance that is documented can be pressed. Put the position on the record where the decision is made: in writing, to the minister and the regulator, in the form DIP 201 teaches, asking that the Crown observe its instruments. And report it. A paper whose own reach has been cut has a story of public interest to tell, to the standard of the first lesson, with the other side’s answer in it.
To practise, take one rule from outside that bears on a paper you know: this Act, a platform’s terms, a rule on advertising. Write three hundred words. Say what the rule provides, in its own words. Say what it has done to the paper, with a figure and a source. State the Nation’s position and Canada’s, each fairly. And say what you would ask for.
The source
Indigenous news outlet means an undertaking or any distinct part of an undertaking whose primary purpose is to produce news content and that (a) is operated by an individual who belongs to an Indigenous group, community or people; and (b) produces news content primarily for Indigenous peoples.Online News Act, section 2(1): “Indigenous news outlet” · S.C. 2023, c. 23; assented to 22 June 2023.
Key terms
- Digital news intermediary
- The Act’s name for a large online platform that makes news available to people in Canada.
- Eligible news business
- A news business that the CRTC has designated as able to bargain under the Act.
- News block
- Meta’s removal of news from Facebook and Instagram for people in Canada, from August 2023.
- Encroachment
- On the Nation’s reading, another government’s law reaching into the acquired territory.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Digital news intermediary, Eligible news business, News block, Encroachment.