Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · PUB 102 Reporting, editing and media law · Lesson 1 of 5

Reporting and verification

Lecture 1 of 5 · about 8 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. When are two sources independent?
  2. What is owed to a person a story criticises?
  3. What happens to the original when a story is corrected?

PUB 101 taught the press of record: where the Nation’s official notices are fixed in print. This course teaches the other work of a newspaper, which is news. The rule from PUB 101 stands over all of it: news is never presented as an official act, and the newspaper keeps its own editorial standards. The standards taught here are journalism’s own.

The Canadian Association of Journalists publishes ethics guidelines under nine heads: accuracy, fairness, the right to privacy, independence, conflict of interest, transparency, promises to sources, diversity and accountability. Accuracy comes first, and the guidelines call it a moral imperative. Two writers on the craft, Bill Kovach and Tom Rosenstiel, put the same thing another way: what separates journalism from other writing is a discipline of verification.

Verification is a method, and it can be learned. For every fact in a story, be able to say how you know it. Prefer the person who was there to the person who heard about it, and the document to anyone’s memory of the document. Read the document yourself. For anything that will be disputed, find a second source that is independent of the first: two people repeating what a third told them are one source. Check every name, title, date and number against a record, and do the arithmetic yourself. HIS 102 taught five questions to ask of an old document, and they serve as well for a press release.

Most news comes from people. Before an interview, read what is already known and write your questions. Say who you are and that you are reporting. Agree the terms before the person speaks, in plain words, since the usual labels mean different things to different people. On the record means that what is said may be published with the speaker’s name. Not for attribution means it may be published without the name. Off the record means it may not be published at all. Take notes, or record with permission, and when a quotation matters check it back with the speaker for accuracy.

Fairness has a working test. Anyone a story accuses or criticises is told exactly what will be said and is given a real chance to answer before it is published, and the answer is reported. A message sent an hour before the deadline is no chance at all. Keep fact and comment apart, as CIV 102 teaches readers to do: a report says what happened, and an opinion is labelled as one.

The picture sets out a reporter’s method in four steps. Read it from left to right.
Find the sourceWho knows, and how?Check itA document; asecond, independentsourceAsk the othersideBefore publishing,with time to answerSay how you knowName sources;correct in the open

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Verification” means. Then read on.

Sources are normally named, so that readers can judge them. The guidelines allow an unnamed source only when the material is of high public interest and cannot be had another way. The editor must know who the source is. A promise of confidence, once given, is kept, so give it rarely. When a source is quoted as an expert, put the six questions of CIV 103 to them first.

Independence is the hardest of the nine in a small community, where everyone is somebody’s cousin. The guidelines ask journalists to keep out of activities they may cover, and to declare publicly any conflict that remains. A reporter does not report on their own family, employer or business. The Nation’s book on its press meets the question openly. It says that the Editor-in-General of the Two Row Times also holds office in the Secretariat, and gives its answer: official notices are always labelled and fingerprinted, the newspaper keeps its own editorial standards, and corrections are public, so that readers can judge each item for what it is. A learner should know that many journalists would ask for more distance than that, and should be able to state both views.

In 2015 the Truth and Reconciliation Commission called on journalism schools to teach every student the history of Aboriginal peoples, the Declaration, treaties and rights, Indigenous law, and relations with the Crown. That is Call to Action 86, and this University’s courses cover that ground. The Anishinaabe journalist Duncan McCue adds practical advice for reporters: take time, learn how a community does things before you arrive with a deadline, ask people how they name themselves and their nation, and never treat one person as speaking for all. This University’s own rule belongs here too. Say whose position a position is, and who contests it.

Every reporter makes mistakes. What counts is what follows. A mistake is corrected promptly and where readers will see it, the correction says what was wrong and what is right, and the original stays on the record. PUB 101 taught the same rule for the Secretariat’s letters.

To practise, report one real event in three hundred words: the meeting you attended for CIV 102 will do. Say who, what, when, where, why and how. Use two sources and one document. Give anyone criticised their answer. Then go through it line by line and mark, beside each fact, how you know it.

The source

Indigenous peoples have the right to establish their own media in their own languages and to have access to all forms of non-indigenous media without discrimination.
United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, article 16(1) · UN General Assembly resolution 61/295, 13 September 2007.

Key terms

Verification
Checking each fact against a source before it is published.
On the record
Said for publication, with the speaker’s name.
Right of reply
The chance for a person criticised to answer before publication.
Independent source
A source whose knowledge does not come from the other source.

Check yourself

1.When are two sources independent?
2.What is owed to a person a story criticises?
3.What happens to the original when a story is corrected?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Verification, On the record, Right of reply, Independent source.