Courses · PUB 102 Reporting, editing and media law · Lesson 3 of 5
Media law: defamation, copyright and the Printer
Lecture 3 of 5 · about 8 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- What must a person suing for defamation show?
- What does the defence in Grant v. Torstar reward?
- Does copyright protect facts?
Two bodies of law stand behind every page a publisher prints: the law of defamation, which protects reputation, and the law of copyright, which protects authors. This lesson describes both as Canadian courts apply them. A newspaper is wise to meet them wherever it is printed, because it can be sued wherever it is read. The lesson is education and is no substitute for a lawyer’s advice on a particular story.
A person who sues for defamation must show three things: that the words would tend to lower their reputation in the eyes of a reasonable person, that the words referred to them, and that the words were published, which means communicated to at least one other person. That is all. The law then presumes that the words were false and that harm was done, and it falls to the publisher to make out a defence.
There are four main defences. The first is truth, which lawyers call justification. The publisher must prove it with evidence a court will accept, which is why reporters keep their notes and documents. The second is fair comment: an opinion on a matter of public interest, recognisable as opinion, based on facts that are true, and one that a person could honestly hold. The third is privilege. What is said in a legislature or a court is protected absolutely, and a fair and accurate report of such public proceedings is protected too. The fourth is the newest.
In 2009, in Grant v. Torstar, the Supreme Court of Canada recognised a defence of responsible communication on matters of public interest. A publisher who gets a fact wrong may still be protected if the story was on a matter of public interest and the publisher was diligent in trying to verify it. The Court listed what will be looked at: how serious the allegation was, how important and how urgent the matter, how reliable the source, whether the other side’s account was sought and accurately reported, and whether including the statement was justified. Read that list beside the first lesson. The law rewards the reporter who did the work.
Some practical points follow. Repeating a defamatory statement is publishing it: “it is alleged that” protects nobody. A headline, a caption or a picture can defame as well as a sentence. In a small community a person can be identified without being named. And a prompt correction and apology reduce the harm, and the damages.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Defamation” means. Then read on.
Copyright protects the expression of an original work: the words, the picture, the recording. It does not protect facts or ideas. It arises the moment the work is made, without any registration, and belongs first to the author. Since 30 December 2022 it lasts in Canada for the author’s life and seventy years more, though works whose term had already run out stayed free. The owner alone may copy and publish the work. So the facts in another newspaper’s story are free to report, and its sentences are not. A photograph found online belongs to whoever took it.
The Act allows some uses without permission, and calls them fair dealing. The section printed below gives five purposes. Two more follow in the Act, criticism or review and news reporting, each on condition that the source and the author are named. A purpose on the list is the first step. The second is that the dealing must be fair, and in 2004, in the case known as CCH, the Supreme Court gave six things to weigh: the purpose, the character of the dealing, the amount taken, the alternatives, the nature of the work, and the effect on the work. The Court called fair dealing a user’s right.
Much of what this University quotes is free for another reason. The instruments of 1779 to 1796 are long out of copyright. Under the Act, works of the Crown are protected for fifty years after the year they are published, and a federal order lets anyone reproduce federal laws and judgments, provided the copy is accurate and is not presented as official. PUB 101 taught the Nation’s own arrangement: Mohawk’s Printer holds the copyright in the Nation’s works in trust for the Nation, a proposed order would leave its laws, Gazette entries and public notices free to copy accurately with their source, and a member’s own book, music or recording remains the member’s.
Before a story goes, ask four questions. Whom could this harm, and can I prove what it says of them? Did they have a real chance to answer? Whose words and pictures are in it besides my own? And for each of those, do I have permission or a fair-dealing ground, and have I named the source?
The source
Fair dealing for the purpose of research, private study, education, parody or satire does not infringe copyright.Copyright Act, section 29 · R.S.C. 1985, c. C-42.
Key terms
- Defamation
- Publishing words that tend to lower a person’s reputation.
- Fair comment
- The defence for honest opinion on a matter of public interest, based on true facts.
- Responsible communication
- The defence for a diligent report on a matter of public interest, even if a fact proves wrong.
- Fair dealing
- Using a copyright work without permission, for a listed purpose and fairly.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Defamation, Fair comment, Responsible communication, Fair dealing.