Courses · LAW 101 The four instruments · Lesson 4 of 4
The Mark and the oath: 1789 and 1796
Lecture 4 of 4 · about 6 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- What defines the class in the 1789 Order?
- Before whom were claimants to be ascertained under the 1796 Proclamation?
- What remedy asks an officer to perform a legal duty?
The first two instruments say who was owed and what was given. The second two say how the class was to be known and proved, and they are the ones most often left out of the story.
Lord Dorchester’s Order in Council of 9 November 1789 was made at Quebec, at a meeting of the Council on the granting of lands. It directed that a register be kept of the Loyalists, so that “their posterity may be discriminated from future settlers”, and that they be distinguished by the capitals U.E. The words are printed below. Three things in them matter to a lawyer. The class is defined by an act and a date: adherence to the unity of the Empire and joining the Royal Standard before the Treaty of Separation of 1783. The honour runs to “all their Children and their Descendants by either sex”. And the means is a register.
The Nation holds that the Mohawk of the three villages are within those words. They adhered; they joined the Royal Standard; they did so before 1783. Nothing in the Order confines it to settlers of European descent.
Simcoe’s Proclamation of 6 April 1796 supplied the procedure. Those claiming the benefit were to be ascertained on oath before the magistrates in their districts, so that the register would rest on sworn proof. The magistrate, today the justice of the peace, is in the Nation’s reading the officer the Crown designated to receive and record the proof.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Register” means. Then read on.
Now notice what never happened. No magistrate sat to take the oaths of the Mohawk class. The register that should have named them was not made for them. The Nation calls this the missing link. A class that was defined in 1779, endowed in 1784 and marked in 1789 was never ascertained as 1796 provided, and every later uncertainty about who the posterity are can be traced to that omission.
It also explains the remedy the Nation seeks first. It has not begun by asking a court to declare who owns the Tract. It asks that the officer designated by the instrument perform the duty the instrument lays on him: receive the proof and record it. An order requiring a public officer to perform a legal duty is called mandamus.
Mandamus has conditions. The applicant must show a clear legal duty, owed to the applicant, that the officer has been asked to perform and has not performed. Each of the four instruments, on the Nation’s reading, supplies part of that showing.
The source
Those Loyalists who have adhered to the Unity of the Empire, and joined the Royal Standard before the Treaty of Separation in the year 1783, and all their Children and their Descendants by either sex, are to be distinguished by the following Capitals, affixed to their names: U.E. Alluding to their great principle The Unity of the Empire.Lord Dorchester’s Order in Council, 9 November 1789 (the Mark of Honour) · As commonly printed from the Council minute.
Key terms
- Register
- The list the 1789 Order directed to be kept of the Loyalists.
- Ascertainment on oath
- Proof of who belongs to the class, sworn before a magistrate.
- Mandamus
- A court’s order that a public officer perform a legal duty.
- Treaty of Separation
- The peace of 1783; the Order’s cut-off date.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Register, Ascertainment on oath, Mandamus, Treaty of Separation.