Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · LAW 101 The four instruments · Lesson 1 of 4

A deed of gift

Lecture 1 of 4 · about 6 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. How does the Nation characterise the 1784 Proclamation?
  2. What did the Crown’s answer to Brant show, on the Nation’s reading?
  3. Whose interest did the 1784 purchase clear, on the Nation’s reading?

What you will be able to do

  • Name the three parts of a gift, and find them in the record.
  • Explain why it matters whether the Tract was given or set apart.
  • Tell a gift from a dedication.

Unit 9 of 28 · the plan

  1. Before the session1 h
  2. The lesson1 h
  3. The case½ h
  4. The seminar1 h
  5. The check¼ h
  6. Hand in½ h

About4¼ hours

The Nation reads the 1784 Proclamation as a deed of gift: the Crown, having bought out the Mississaugas’ interest, gave the land to the Mohawk and their posterity.

When Brant later sought a better title, the Nation’s account is that the Crown answered that a deed of gift was the highest right it could give. The Nation reads that answer as the Crown confirming it had nothing left to give.

A gift in law has three parts: the intention to give, delivery, and acceptance. The Nation finds all three on the record. The intention is in the Proclamation’s own words, which give the reason, “the early attachment to his cause manifested by the Mohawk Indians, and … the loss of their settlement”. Delivery is the instrument itself, under the Governor’s hand and seal at arms. Acceptance is the fact of settlement: the Mohawk came, and stayed.

Why does it matter whether the Tract was given or merely set apart? A gift passes the interest to the one who receives it. Land merely set apart remains the giver’s, to be managed for others. Every later argument about who may sell, lease, tax or surrender the Tract turns on which of these happened in 1784.

A gift has three parts. Read the cards left to right; the foot of each says where the Nation finds that part on the record.
IntentionThe Crown means to give, andsays why.The Proclamation’s recitalDeliveryThe instrument passes underhand and seal.25 October 1784AcceptanceThe Mohawk come and settle.Settlement on the Grand

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Deed of gift” means. Then read on.

The purchase from the Mississaugas in May 1784 supports the first reading, the Nation says. The Crown paid to clear a competing interest before it granted. It is the conduct of a giver making good title, and it also means that those who sold kept nothing in the Tract to claim later.

The Nation prefers “deed of gift” to “dedication”. A dedication gives land to public use and leaves the public as its beneficiary; the doctrine was argued in Hopton v Pamajewon. The Proclamation gave to a named class, the Mohawk and others of the Six Nations who chose to settle, and to their posterity. A class of persons is not the public.

When Brant pressed for a firmer title, the answer he received, as the Nation tells it, was that a deed of gift was the highest right the Crown could give. Read that answer twice. It says the Crown had already given all it had to give, which is why the Nation holds that the Patent of 1793 had nothing left to convey.

Test the reading yourself. Find the three parts of a gift in the extract below, and then ask what words you would expect to see if the Crown had meant only to lend the land, or to hold it for others. Are any of them there?

The source

Whereas His Majesty having been pleased to direct that in consideration of the early attachment to his cause manifested by the Mohawk Indians, and of the loss of their settlement which they thereby sustained, that a convenient tract of land under his protection should be chosen as a safe and comfortable retreat for them and others of the Six Nations […] I do hereby in His Majesty’s name authorize and permit the said Mohawk Nation, and such others of the Six Nation Indians as wish to settle in that quarter, to take possession of and settle upon the banks of the river commonly called Ouse or Grand River, running into Lake Erie, allotting to them for that purpose six miles deep from each side of the river beginning at Lake Erie and extending in that proportion to the head of the said river, which them and their posterity are to enjoy for ever.
The Haldimand Proclamation, 25 October 1784 (extract) · From the printed Crown text.

This lesson as a unit

Before the session1 hour

Read. The extract in the lesson, and St Catherine’s Milling (1888).

Bring 150 words. What words would you expect if the Crown had meant only to lend the land?

The case: The applicant’s file½ hour

The applicant’s file. The applicant is made up: a descendant whose family says it came from Canajoharie. Enter the Nation’s reading: the Tract given by a deed of gift. Note what follows for the file if the reading holds, and if it does not.

The seminar1 hour, live

Find intention, delivery and acceptance in the extract. Then argue the other side: what would “set apart” require?

Path A · starting outThe three parts defined, with one found for you.
Path B · officers and professionalsWrite the reading as a short brief, with the answer it must meet.

Hand in: casebook entry 9 · Given, or set apart?½ hour

The three parts of a gift, each found in the record. Marked to a published guide, with written feedback in three parts: what the evidence supports, what is still assumed, and what to do next.

Key terms

Deed of gift
An instrument giving property without payment.
Interest
A legal right in land, short of or including ownership.
Delivery
Handing over the instrument so that the gift takes effect.

The questions of this lesson

  1. Choose oneHow does the Nation characterise the 1784 Proclamation?
    1. A licence to hunt
    2. A deed of gift
    3. A lease
  2. Choose oneWhat did the Crown’s answer to Brant show, on the Nation’s reading?
    1. It wanted rent
    2. It had nothing higher left to give
    3. It would revoke the grant
  3. Choose oneWhose interest did the 1784 purchase clear, on the Nation’s reading?
    1. A competing interest, the Mississaugas’
    2. The Americans’
    3. The band council’s

They are answered and marked in My Register, where this sample lesson is open to every member: there it asks 7 questions in all, in two ways, with how sure you are and what is still unclear. No answers are published on this site.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Deed of gift, Interest, Delivery.

Sample questions of the test →

This was the sample lesson

The four instruments has three more lessons, each with its reading, its terms and its self-check, and a test drawn from the whole course. They are for enrolled learners, in My Register.

The first lesson is open to everyone. The full course is $60, and free for members of the Nation. What it costs