Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · LAW 101 The four instruments · Lesson 2 of 4

Enjoyment, not occupation

Lecture 2 of 4 · about 6 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. In the Proclamation, “enjoy” means…
  2. Which does the Nation say the Mohawk class holds?
  3. “Enjoyment” in the Proclamation is…

The Proclamation says the posterity are to enjoy the land for ever. The Nation uses enjoyment in its legal sense: the underlying interest, the right to have the benefit of the land, not a feeling and not mere presence on it.

It contrasts exclusive use and enjoyment, individual and hereditary, with exclusive use and occupation, the collective test used in section 35 cases.

The difference is easiest to see in what each must prove. To establish Aboriginal title a group must show that it occupied the land exclusively at the time the Crown asserted sovereignty: Delgamuukw (1997) and Tsilhqot’in Nation (2014). The proof is of long use by a community, shown through oral history, archaeology and the accounts of early visitors.

To establish enjoyment under a grant, one proves the grant and one’s place in the class. The proof is documentary: the instrument, and a line of descent to a person within it. No one needs to show how the land was used in 1784, or before, because the right does not arise from use.

Two phrases that sound alike and lead to different law. Compare the columns line by line: who holds, how it is proved, and whether it can be lost.
Use and enjoymentArises from a Crown grantHeld by each of the posterity, byinheritanceProved by the instrument and a line ofdescentRuns “for ever”, to those not yet bornUse and occupationArises from prior occupationHeld by a group, collectivelyProved by exclusive occupation atsovereigntyA section 35 right, subject to justifiedlimits

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Enjoyment” means. Then read on.

The holders differ as well. Aboriginal title is held by the group and cannot be sold except to the Crown. An interest under a grant to named persons and their posterity is held, the Nation says, by each member of the posterity as an inheritance. It comes to a child at birth, from either parent, whatever band that child may or may not belong to.

So do the consequences. Occupation can be lost: a community can be found to have ceased to occupy. Enjoyment under a grant “for ever” to a posterity that includes the unborn cannot run out, on the Nation’s reading, because there is always a member of the class who has not yet been born and so cannot have given anything up.

Keep the two phrases apart whenever you read about the Tract. When a writer says “use and occupation”, the frame is section 35 and a collective. When the Proclamation says “enjoy”, the Nation hears a term of property law as old as the common law’s promise of quiet enjoyment.

A good exercise is to rewrite the Proclamation’s last clause both ways. First as a grant of enjoyment to a posterity, as it stands. Then as a recognition of occupation by a community. Notice how much of the second version you have to invent: a date of sovereignty, a description of use, a community to hold it. The original needs none of these, because it does a different job.

Key terms

Enjoyment
In law, having the benefit of an interest.
Use and occupation
The collective test applied in Aboriginal title cases.
Aboriginal title
A collective right to land arising from exclusive occupation at sovereignty.

Check yourself

1.In the Proclamation, “enjoy” means…
2.Which does the Nation say the Mohawk class holds?
3.“Enjoyment” in the Proclamation is…

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Enjoyment, Use and occupation, Aboriginal title.