Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · LAW 101 The four instruments · Lesson 3 of 4

What the instruments do not say

Lecture 3 of 4 · about 6 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. How do the instruments define the class, on the Nation’s reading?
  2. What duty does the Nation say follows?
  3. Which of these does the Nation say the instruments do not mention?

The Nation points out that the four instruments speak of no Indigenous customs and define the class by adherence and named villages, not by clan or by occupation.

From that it reads the Tract as acquired territory, held by grant, rather than ancestral land, and so outside section 35. On that footing it speaks of a duty to observe the grant, rather than a duty to consult about it.

Set the four side by side and list what each names. The Pledge names villages and a reason. The Proclamation names a river, a measure and a posterity. The Order of 1789 names a mark and a register. The Proclamation of 1796 names an oath and a magistrate. Nowhere is there a word about hunting grounds, clans, councils or customs.

The Nation draws a careful inference from that silence. The class the instruments define is not a people described by its culture. It is a set of persons described by an act, adherence to the Crown, and by where they had lived when they did it. That is how the common law describes a class in a grant or a will: by a fact that can be proved.

Each row is one instrument; the columns show what it names. Read across, and note that no column is headed customs, clans or occupation.
InstrumentNamesDefines the class by1779 PledgeThree villages; a promiseAttachment to the King’sservice1784 ProclamationA river; six miles; posterityThe Mohawk Nation and otherswho settle1789 OrderU.E.; a registerAdherence before 1783, byeither sex1796 ProclamationAn oath; a magistrateSworn proof

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Acquired territory” means. Then read on.

From this the Nation reads the Tract as acquired territory. In the law of nations, territory is acquired when a people comes to hold it by a recognised title, such as cession or grant, as distinct from holding it from time out of mind. The Mohawk did not hold the Grand River valley before 1784; they received it then.

If that is right, section 35 is the wrong frame, because section 35 protects rights that arise from prior occupation and from treaties. The Nation places the interest under section 109 instead, as “any Interest other than that of the Province”.

It also changes the duty. The duty to consult, as the Supreme Court set it out in Haida Nation (2004), arises where the Crown knows of a claim that has not yet been proved. The Nation observes that to accept consultation is to accept that description. A proved grant asks for something simpler: that the Crown, and all who hold under the Crown, observe it.

Critics answer that the Mohawk were an Indigenous nation long before 1779, with customs and laws of their own, and that no instrument could make them otherwise. The Nation does not disagree. Its point is narrower: the right to this Tract comes from these instruments, and they must be read for what they say.

The source

By His Excellency General Haldimand, Esq., Captain General and Commander-in-Chief of the Province of Quebec, and upon the frontiers of Quebec, etc. Some of the Mohawks of the Villages of Canojaharie, Tikondarago, and Aughugo, whose settlements than had been on account of their steady attachment to the King’s service and the interests of Government ruined by the rebels; having informed me that my predecessor, Sir Guy Carleton, was pleased to promise, as soon as the present troubles were at an end, the same should be restored at the expense of the Government, to the state they were in before the wars broke out, and said promise appearing to me just, I do hereby ratify the same and assure them the said promise, so far as in me lies, shall be faithfully executed, as soon as that happy time comes. GIVEN UNDER MY HAND AND SEAL at Quebec the 7th day of April, 1779. Signed: FRED HALDIMAND
The Haldimand Pledge, 7 April 1779 · Text as printed in secondary sources.

Key terms

Acquired territory
Land held by acquisition, here by grant.
Duty to observe
The Nation’s term for the obligation to honour the grant as made.
Class
Persons defined by a fact that can be proved.

Check yourself

1.How do the instruments define the class, on the Nation’s reading?
2.What duty does the Nation say follows?
3.Which of these does the Nation say the instruments do not mention?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Acquired territory, Duty to observe, Class.