Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · FAC 106 Teaching contested history and law · Lesson 4 of 4

Hard histories

Lecture 4 of 4 · about 7 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. What is giving notice for?
  2. May a task require a learner to write about their own family’s suffering?
  3. What should a history of harm also show?

Some of what this University teaches is painful, and for many learners it is family history. The residential school at Brantford, the Mohawk Institute, took children from the Grand River for more than a century and closed only in 1970. The Indian Act removed people from their own nation by rule. Families were divided over who belonged. An instructor will meet people who lived these things, or whose parents did.

These histories must be taught. The Commission’s first Call on education, printed below, asks for exactly that in every school. Leaving them out, to spare feelings, tells those who lived them that their experience is unspeakable. The question is how.

First, give notice. Say at the start of a lesson, and in the course outline, what it contains. This is no apology for the content. It lets a person choose when and where to meet it. Nobody should be surprised by their own family’s grief in a room full of strangers.

Second, never require disclosure. Do not ask who had relatives at the school. Do not set a task that requires a learner to write about their own family’s suffering; offer it as one choice among several. If someone chooses to speak, listen, thank them, and do not turn their account into the class’s material without their leave.

Third, let people leave. A learner may step out without explaining and return without comment. Arrange beforehand how they can make up what they missed.

The table lists seven rules for teaching a painful history. Read across: the rule, and why.
Do thisBecauseGive noticePeople can choose how to meet itNever require disclosureA story is the teller’s ownLet people leaveNobody should have to explainTeach from published accounts, with creditSurvivors chose what to make publicTeach more than harmA people is more than what was done to itKnow the supportsYou are a teacher, not a counsellorLook after yourselfThe material wears on the teacher too

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Notice” means. Then read on.

Fourth, teach from the record and from survivors’ own published words, and name them. The Commission gathered thousands of statements, and many survivors have written and spoken publicly. Use what they chose to make public, with credit. Do not dramatise, and do not show images of suffering for effect. The facts are heavy enough.

Fifth, teach more than harm. The same people who were sent to the school kept the language, kept the records, went to Geneva, served in two world wars and raised the families the learners come from. A history that shows only what was done to a people misrepresents them. The University’s courses on the alliance, on diplomacy and on art are part of teaching the hard history honestly.

Sixth, know what support exists before you need it. Have the telephone numbers of crisis and counselling services on a page learners can find, and check twice a year that they still work. In Canada the Hope for Wellness Help Line serves Indigenous people at any hour, at 1-855-242-3310. You are a teacher and not a counsellor, and the kindest thing you can do for a person in distress is to stay with them calmly and connect them with someone trained.

Seventh, look after yourself. Teaching this material term after term wears on a person, the more so if it is your own family’s history. Talk to colleagues. Take the same care you would ask a learner to take.

Where a lesson touches ceremony, or anything held by particular people, it is not the University’s to teach, and the lesson should say so and stop. The reviews by knowledge keepers that each course records exist partly to catch what an instructor would not know to leave out.

The source

Make age-appropriate curriculum on residential schools, Treaties, and Aboriginal peoples’ historical and contemporary contributions to Canada a mandatory education requirement for Kindergarten to Grade Twelve students.
Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada, Call to Action 62(i) · Calls to Action, 2015.

Key terms

Notice
Telling learners in advance what a lesson contains, so they can choose how to meet it.
Disclosure
A person’s telling of their own experience; never to be required.
Survivor
A person who attended a residential school.

Check yourself

1.What is giving notice for?
2.May a task require a learner to write about their own family’s suffering?
3.What should a history of harm also show?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Notice, Disclosure, Survivor.