Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · FAC 106 Teaching contested history and law · Lesson 3 of 4

Fairness to the other side

Lecture 3 of 4 · about 7 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. What must you be able to state for each claim you teach?
  2. Which word gives an instructor away?
  3. To what is fairness not owed?

The sentence printed below was written in 1859, and it is the best single piece of advice for anyone teaching a contested subject. A person who cannot state the case against their own position does not really know their position. They know a conclusion.

So the University asks its instructors to do something harder than attribution. For every claim of the Nation that a course teaches, be able to state the strongest objection to it, in a form its holders would accept as fair. Philosophers call this the principle of charity. Debaters call it steelmanning, the opposite of setting up a straw man.

Take a real example. The Nation holds that the Grand River lands were reclassified as a reserve by reading the grant of 1784 through a patent of 1793 that the Mohawk did not accept. The strongest objection is no caricature. It is a judgment of the Supreme Court of Canada, Isaac v. Davey, in 1977, which held that the lands are a reserve within the meaning of the Indian Act. An instructor must be able to say what the Court decided, on what reasoning, and why the Nation holds that the reasoning does not reach its position. A learner who has heard only the Nation’s side will be undone by the first lawyer who cites the case.

There are four tests of whether you have been fair. Could a holder of the other view read your account of it and say, “yes, that is what we think”? Have you given its best argument, and not its weakest? Have you given its evidence, and not only its conclusion? And have you kept your tone the same for both sides? Adjectives give instructors away. If one side “argues” and the other “claims” or “alleges”, the class has been told what to think.

The table gives four tests of fairness. Read across: the test, and how to apply it.
TestAsk yourselfRecognitionWould its holders say “yes, that is what wethink”?StrengthHave I given its best argument?EvidenceHave I given its evidence, and not only itsconclusion?ToneDo both sides “argue”, or does one “allege”?

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Principle of charity” means. Then read on.

Fairness has a limit, which the first lesson gave. It is owed to positions held by informed people on open questions. It is not owed to denial of documented fact. And it does not require you to pretend that all positions are equally well supported. After setting out both sides fairly, you may say which you find stronger and why. That is a judgment, labelled as one, and the learners are free to weigh it.

Fairness also applies inside the Nation’s world. The Mohawk Nation of Grand River speaks for itself and not for the Confederacy, the elected council or other Mohawk communities, and they do not speak for it. Where those bodies hold different positions, state them as theirs, accurately, and without scorn. Learners may have family on every side.

Why hold to this when the other side has not always been fair in return? Because the Nation’s case rests on documents, and documents reward careful reading. A habit of exactness about what others hold is the same habit as exactness about what a proclamation says. It is also what makes a graduate of this University believable in a room that did not expect to believe them.

To practise, choose one claim from a course’s Master Content Card. Write the objection to it in a paragraph, as its best advocate would. Then show the paragraph to someone who holds that view, if you can, and ask whether you got it right.

The source

He who knows only his own side of the case, knows little of that.
John Stuart Mill, On Liberty (1859), chapter 2 · London: John W. Parker and Son, 1859.

Key terms

Principle of charity
Stating another’s position in its strongest and fairest form.
Straw man
A weak version of a position, set up to be knocked down.
Counter-reading
A reading opposed to the one being taught.

Check yourself

1.What must you be able to state for each claim you teach?
2.Which word gives an instructor away?
3.To what is fairness not owed?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Principle of charity, Straw man, Counter-reading.