Courses · FAC 106 Teaching contested history and law · Lesson 1 of 4
A reading, with its source
Lecture 1 of 4 · about 7 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- What should learners see before any interpretation?
- Which sentence needs attribution?
- Is it honest to present a documented fact as “one view”?
Much of what this University teaches is contested. The Nation reads the Crown’s instruments one way. Canada and Ontario read them another. Other bodies at the Grand River read them a third. A course that presented the Nation’s reading as plain fact would be easy to write and would fail its learners the first time they met someone who disagreed. The University’s rule is that a position is taught as a position.
Three layers have to be kept apart. The first is the text: what a document says, in its own words. The Proclamation printed below says what it says, and nobody disputes the words. The second is a reading: what someone holds that the text means or does. That the Proclamation gives exclusive use and enjoyment is the Nation’s reading. The third is the contest: who reads it otherwise, and on what ground.
Teach all three, in that order, and label each. Put the source in front of the learners first, before any interpretation, and let them read it cold. Ask what it says. Then give the reading, and say whose it is: “the Nation holds”, “the Supreme Court held in 1977”, “a historian has argued”. Then ask the question the whole method turns on: does the source bear the reading? Let them argue it from the words.
This is why every lesson prints its primary source, and why every course has a Master Content Card that lists its claims and who contests them. Use the card. It is on each course’s page, and it was written so that an instructor would never have to guess which statements are settled and which are in dispute.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Reading” means. Then read on.
Attribution has a grammar. “The Tract is six miles deep on each side of the river” is a statement about the text and needs no attribution: the words are there. “The interest is preserved by section 109” is a reading and needs its holder. Listen to your own sentences as you teach. The ones that begin “of course” or “obviously” are usually readings.
Do not overcorrect. Some things are facts and should be taught as facts. The Pledge was given in 1779. The residential school at Brantford operated until 1970. To present a documented fact as “one view” is as dishonest as presenting a reading as fact, and it is a favourite device of people who wish to deny what happened.
Teaching this way is no weakness in the Nation’s position. A learner who has tested a reading against its source, and heard the objections, holds it more firmly than one who was simply told. And a learner who concludes otherwise has done what a university exists to let people do. The Nation’s case is served by people who can argue it. People who can only recite it are of little use to it.
To practise, take the passage below and write three sentences about it: one that states the text, one that states a reading with its holder, and one that states who contests the reading and why.
The source
Whereas His Majesty having been pleased to direct that in consideration of the early attachment to his cause manifested by the Mohawk Indians, and of the loss of their settlement which they thereby sustained, that a convenient tract of land under his protection should be chosen as a safe and comfortable retreat for them and others of the Six Nations […] I do hereby in His Majesty’s name authorize and permit the said Mohawk Nation, and such others of the Six Nation Indians as wish to settle in that quarter, to take possession of and settle upon the banks of the river commonly called Ouse or Grand River, running into Lake Erie, allotting to them for that purpose six miles deep from each side of the river beginning at Lake Erie and extending in that proportion to the head of the said river, which them and their posterity are to enjoy for ever.The Haldimand Proclamation, 25 October 1784 · Given at Quebec; signed Fred. Haldimand.
Key terms
- Reading
- What someone holds that a text means or does.
- Attribution
- Saying whose a reading is.
- Master Content Card
- A course’s list of key facts, claims and who contests them.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Reading, Attribution, Master Content Card.