Courses · FAC 106 Teaching contested history and law · Lesson 2 of 4
Disagreement in the room
Lecture 2 of 4 · about 7 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- How should a settled question be taught?
- What is the point of exchanging sides?
- What is never acceptable?
A class that studies contested questions will disagree, and it should. The instructor’s work is to make the disagreement useful. That takes planning.
Begin by sorting your questions. The American scholar Diana Hess distinguishes settled questions from open ones. A settled question has an answer supported by overwhelming evidence, or one a decent society has stopped debating: whether the residential schools did harm is settled. An open question is one on which informed, reasonable people disagree: how section 109 applies to the Tract is open. Teach settled questions as settled. Give open questions the full treatment. Presenting a settled matter as open is a failure, and so is the reverse. If you are unsure which a question is, that is worth discussing with a colleague before class.
Agree the rules before the argument starts. Ideas are challenged and people are not. Speak for yourself: “I think” and not “everyone knows”. Give reasons and point to sources. Listen to the end. Anyone may pass. And nobody is asked to speak for a whole people.
Then give the disagreement a structure, so that it does not belong to the loudest. One method, used in schools and colleges for decades, is the structured academic controversy. Learners work in fours. One pair is given a position and prepares its best case from the sources. The other pair is given the opposite. Each pair presents while the other listens and then repeats back what it heard, to the first pair’s satisfaction. Then the pairs exchange positions and argue the other side. Last, all four drop their assigned sides and try to write a statement they can all sign, noting where they still differ.
The exchange of sides is the point of the method. Nobody is asked to defend what they personally believe, so nobody is exposed. Everybody has to state a view they may dislike well enough to satisfy its holders. Most people find the other side stronger than they expected, and their own position clearer.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Settled question” means. Then read on.
What of your own view? Learners will ask. There are honest instructors who say and honest ones who decline, and either can be right. If you say, say it late, say that it is yours, and make it plain by your marking that agreement earns nothing. If you decline, say why. What is never acceptable is to pretend to neutrality while steering.
Watch for the learner who is alone. When one person holds a view against the room, protect their right to hold it, restate it fairly yourself, and thank them. A class learns more from one dissenter than from an hour of agreement.
When feeling runs high, slow down. Stop the discussion, ask everyone to write for two minutes on what they have heard, and resume with a round in which each person speaks once. Go back to the source. Heat usually falls when people return to the words on the page.
The Commission’s phrase printed below names what this is for. Intercultural understanding, empathy and mutual respect are capacities, and they are built by practice of this kind.
The source
Building student capacity for intercultural understanding, empathy, and mutual respect.Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada, Call to Action 63(iii) · Calls to Action, 2015.
Key terms
- Settled question
- One with an answer supported by overwhelming evidence.
- Open question
- One on which informed, reasonable people disagree.
- Structured academic controversy
- A discussion method in which pairs argue assigned sides, exchange them, then seek a common statement.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Settled question, Open question, Structured academic controversy.