Courses · STR 101 Strategy and alliance: the classical texts and the Mohawk at war · Lesson 5 of 5
Case study: 1812, and strategy without an army
Lecture 5 of 5 · about 7 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- What did the Grand River warriors do at Queenston Heights?
- How does the Treaty of Ghent differ from the Treaty of Paris of 1783?
- Which instruments of power remain to a nation without the military one?
Thirty years after the Mohawk came to the Grand River, the United States invaded Upper Canada, and the circle of kings turned again. The Crown had few regular soldiers in the province, and once more it needed its allies.
On 13 October 1812 an American force crossed the Niagara River and took the heights above Queenston. General Brock was killed leading a charge against them. While British reinforcements marched from Fort George, a party of Grand River warriors under John Norton and the young John Brant climbed the escarpment by a path inland and attacked. They were perhaps eighty against more than a thousand. For several hours they kept the Americans pinned on the heights, unable to form or to dig in, until the reinforcements arrived and the invaders surrendered. On 24 June 1813, at Beaver Dams, warriors from Kahnawà:ke and other villages of Lower Canada, with a party from the Grand River, ambushed an American column in the woods and compelled nearly five hundred men to surrender.
The war was hard on the Grand River. It set relatives on the American side against those on the British, the settlement was fought over, and there were seasons when its people hesitated. But consider the peace. The treaty signed at Ghent in December 1814 contains the article printed below. Each side undertook to restore to the nations it had fought everything they had held in 1811. In 1783 the allies were absent from the treaty. In 1814 they are in it. The difference came from thirty years of pressing the point, and from being needed again at the right moment.
Then the leverage fell, as Kautilya would have predicted. After 1815 the border was quiet. The Crown no longer needed warriors, and within a generation its officials were treating the nations as a charge on the treasury where they had once been allies. The alliance had rested on being needed in war, and when the wars stopped it had to rest on something else. The only thing left was the written record of what had been promised.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Beaver Dams” means. Then read on.
That brings the course to the present, and to its last question. What is the strategy of a nation that does not rely on arms? Work it through with the war-college model.
The ends are the Nation’s own to state, and DIP 301 sets them out. The means are these. There are the Crown’s own instruments, which the other side cannot disown. There is a Register that can show who the people are, and a record of every question asked and every answer given. There is a press that publishes the record. There are a people’s time and patience. And there is the standing that comes from three centuries of conduct as an ally.
The ways follow from Sun Tzu’s ranking. Do not attack the cities, which here means do not start with what the other side will defend to the end. Work on plans and alliances. Ask questions that an office cannot answer without conceding the point. Make friends among those whose interests run alongside yours. Be exact, and be on the record. Of the four instruments of power, three remain to a people without the military one, and each can be built up: the diplomatic, the informational and the economic.
Then look for the tilt in the stool. The ends are large and the means are small, and the honest name for the gap is risk. Strategy does not remove it. It asks that the gap be seen, that the nearer goals be chosen within reach of the means, and that each one gained add to the means for the next.
The source
The United States of America engage to put an end immediately after the Ratification of the present Treaty to hostilities with all the Tribes or Nations of Indians with whom they may be at war at the time of such Ratification, and forthwith to restore to such Tribes or Nations respectively all the possessions, rights, and privileges which they may have enjoyed or been entitled to in one thousand eight hundred and eleven previous to such hostilities.The Treaty of Ghent, 24 December 1814, article 9 · Between Great Britain and the United States of America. The article goes on to bind His Britannic Majesty in the same words.
Key terms
- Queenston Heights
- The battle of 13 October 1812, in which Grand River warriors held an American force until reinforcements came.
- Beaver Dams
- The action of 24 June 1813, won by warriors from Kahnawà:ke and other villages, with a Grand River party.
- Treaty of Ghent
- The peace of 1814 between Britain and the United States; article 9 concerns the nations.
- Risk
- In strategy, the gap between ends and the means to reach them.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Queenston Heights, Beaver Dams, Treaty of Ghent, Risk.