Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · STR 101 Strategy and alliance: the classical texts and the Mohawk at war · Lesson 3 of 5

Thucydides: fear, honour and interest

Lecture 3 of 5 · about 7 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. What did Thucydides consider the real cause of the war?
  2. Which three motives do his Athenians name?
  3. What followed the destruction of Melos in his account?

The oldest case study in the staff-college curriculum is a war fought in Greece between 431 and 404 BCE. Athens, a sea power with an empire of island allies, fought Sparta, a land power with a league of its own. The war lasted twenty-seven years, drew in nearly every Greek city and ended in the ruin of Athens. Its historian, Thucydides, was an Athenian general who was exiled for losing a battle and spent his exile finding out what had happened. He wrote, he said, for those who want to understand the future by the past.

Three passages in his book are read by every student of strategy, and each bears on a small nation.

The first is on causes. Thucydides separates the complaints each side made in public from what he considers the real cause, which he says was least spoken of: Athens had grown powerful, and this alarmed Sparta. A rising power and a frightened one are a dangerous pair, and the quarrel that finally starts the war is often a small one between their allies. This war began over two minor cities. The lesson for an ally is sobering. Great powers are sometimes pulled into wars by their small friends, and small friends are always pulled in by their great ones.

The second is on motives, in the sentence printed below. Athenian envoys, explaining to the Spartans how their empire came about, name three things that move states: fear, honour and interest. The list has never been improved on. When you try to work out what another government will do, ask what it is afraid of, what it thinks its standing requires, and what it stands to gain. Ask the same of your own side. Honour is the one modern analysts forget. A government will often pay a real price to avoid looking as though it has backed down, and a wise negotiator leaves it a way to agree without doing so.

Three cards, one for each motive. Read each from the top: the motive, the question to ask of another government, and the same question turned on yourself.
FearWhat is it afraid of?And what are we afraid of?HonourWhat does it think itsstanding requires?Have we left it a way toagree?InterestWhat does it stand to gain?Where do our interests meet?

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Fear, honour and interest” means. Then read on.

The third is the dialogue at Melos, which you met in DIP 101. Melos was a small island that wished to stay neutral. Athens demanded that it submit. The Melians argued from justice, and from their hope that Sparta would come to their aid. The Athenians answered that hope is a comfort for those who can afford it. Sparta did not come. Melos was destroyed.

What should a small nation learn from Melos? Some read it as proof that only power counts. But follow the story on. The very next thing Thucydides relates is the Athenian expedition to Sicily, launched in the same confidence, which destroyed their fleet and army and lost them the war. The arrogance of the dialogue is the cause of the disaster. Power that recognises no limit finds one.

The practical lessons are narrower. Neutrality has to be guaranteed by someone whose interest it serves, or it is only a wish. An ally must be chosen for its interest in your survival, since its sympathy will not move it. A promise of help should be had in writing and, where possible, in advance. And a small nation’s case in justice, though it will not save it on the day, is the thing that is remembered and can be acted on afterwards. The Mohawk’s own history, in the next lesson, shows every one of these.

The source

And the nature of the case first compelled us to advance our empire to its present height; fear being our principal motive, though honour and interest afterwards came in.
Thucydides, History of the Peloponnesian War, book 1, chapter 75: the Athenians at Sparta · Translated by Richard Crawley, 1874.

Key terms

Peloponnesian War
The war between Athens and Sparta, 431 to 404 BCE.
Fear, honour and interest
The three motives of states, as Thucydides’ Athenians name them.
Melian dialogue
Thucydides’ account of Athens’ demand that neutral Melos submit.
Guarantor
A power whose own interest leads it to protect another’s neutrality or safety.

Check yourself

1.What did Thucydides consider the real cause of the war?
2.Which three motives do his Athenians name?
3.What followed the destruction of Melos in his account?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Peloponnesian War, Fear, honour and interest, Melian dialogue, Guarantor.