Courses · STR 101 Strategy and alliance: the classical texts and the Mohawk at war · Lesson 1 of 5
What strategy is
Lecture 1 of 5 · about 7 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- What are the three parts of strategy in the war-college model?
- What did Clausewitz say war is?
- Which is an instrument of power?
Armies send their most promising officers back to school in mid-career. Canada’s are sent to the Canadian Forces College in Toronto for a year, where the courses include Command and Military Theory, and International Security and Canadian Foreign Policy. American naval officers take a course called Strategy and War, which begins with the classical theorists and proceeds through case studies from the Peloponnesian War to the present. This course follows the same plan on a small scale: the theorists first, then two cases. The cases are the Mohawk’s own.
Why should a nation that does not rely on arms study strategy? There are three reasons. The states it deals with think this way, and a diplomat should understand them. The Mohawk’s own history turned on two wars and two peace treaties. And strategy is the art of getting what you need with what you have, against someone who would prefer you did not. That describes every contest, including those fought with letters.
The definition used at the war colleges is plain. Strategy is the matching of ends, ways and means. Ends are what you want. Means are what you have. Ways are how you use the one to reach the other. Colonel Arthur Lykke, who taught the model, drew it as a stool with three legs. If the ends are too great for the means, or the ways do not connect them, the stool tilts, and the tilt is the risk you are carrying. Most failures of strategy are a refusal to look at the tilt.
The means are more than soldiers. Staff colleges list four instruments of power: diplomatic, informational, military and economic. A state uses all four together, and a people that lacks one must be the stronger in the others.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Strategy” means. Then read on.
There are levels. Policy sets the purpose. Strategy decides how the instruments will serve it. Operations arrange campaigns. Tactics win engagements. It is possible to win every engagement and lose the war, if the levels are not joined.
The thinker who saw this most clearly was Carl von Clausewitz, a Prussian officer who fought Napoleon and spent the rest of his life working out what he had seen. His book On War was published in 1832, after his death. Its central sentence is printed below. War is an instrument of policy. It is never an end in itself, and it must always be judged by whether it serves the political purpose. From this follows the question he says must be asked first: what kind of contest is this, and what is it for?
Clausewitz gave strategy three more ideas that every officer learns. Friction: in real conflict everything is simple and the simplest thing is difficult, because people tire, messages go astray and it rains. Fog: decisions are made on information that is incomplete and partly wrong. And the trinity: every war is shaped by three forces together, the passion of the people, the play of chance that the commander must handle, and the reason of the government. Neglect any one and the others pull the enterprise off course.
Keep the first question beside you through the rest of the course. Before any contest, of any kind: what is it for?
The source
War is a mere continuation of policy by other means. We see, therefore, that War is not merely a political act, but also a real political instrument, a continuation of political commerce, a carrying out of the same by other means.Carl von Clausewitz, On War, book I, chapter 1, section 24 · Translated by Colonel J. J. Graham, 1873.
Key terms
- Strategy
- The matching of ends, ways and means against an opponent.
- Instruments of power
- Diplomatic, informational, military and economic.
- Friction
- Clausewitz’s word for everything that makes the simple difficult in real conflict.
- Policy
- The political purpose that strategy serves.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Strategy, Instruments of power, Friction, Policy.