Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · STR 101 Strategy and alliance: the classical texts and the Mohawk at war · Lesson 4 of 5

Case study: the Mohawk Valley, 1775 to 1783

Lecture 4 of 5 · about 7 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. Why was neutrality a weak choice for the Mohawk in 1775?
  2. Who is missing from article 7 of the Treaty of Paris?
  3. When is an ally’s leverage highest?

The American naval staff course takes the War of American Independence as its third case. This lesson takes the same war from the Mohawk River, and asks the staff college’s questions of it.

First, the situation. In 1775 the Mohawk were few, perhaps four hundred people in their two valley towns, living among settlers who outnumbered them many times and who wanted their fields. Their ends were plain: to keep their homeland and their standing as a people. Their means were a few hundred fighting men, their knowledge of the country, a position on the road between Albany and the Great Lakes, and an alliance with the Crown that was a century old.

They had three ways open. They could stay neutral, as both sides at first urged. They could join the colonists. Or they could keep their alliance. Apply Thucydides. Their fear was the settlers on their boundary. Their interest lay with the only power that had drawn a line against settlement, in the Proclamation of 1763 and at Fort Stanwix in 1768. Their honour was engaged by the chain. Neutrality had no guarantor: whoever won would owe them nothing. Joseph Brant went to London to test the Crown’s commitment, came back satisfied, and argued for war.

The decision was not unanimous among the Six Nations, and the cost of that was high. The Oneida and Tuscarora leaned to the colonists. Early in 1777 their central council fire was covered. At Oriskany, on 6 August of that year, warriors of the confederacy fought on both sides. This is the division Sun Tzu warned of.

The line shows the Mohawk’s war in order. Read it from left to right. The filled circles are acts of war; the open circles are papers.
1775Brant sailsfor London1777Oriskany: theSix Nationsdivided1778Aughgugoburned1779The Pledge, inwriting1783Peace ofParis: alliesleft out1784TheProclamation

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Oriskany” means. Then read on.

In the field the Mohawk and their allies fought the war they were suited to. From Niagara they struck the frontier settlements that fed Washington’s army, and for four years they held down forces many times their number. By the measure of tactics and operations this was a success. But the valley was lost. Aughgugo was burned in the autumn of 1778, the two Mohawk River towns were abandoned to the enemy, and in 1779 an American army burned some forty towns of the Seneca and Cayuga. The Mohawk spent the rest of the war as refugees at Niagara and near Montreal.

The war was decided elsewhere. A British army surrendered at Yorktown in 1781, and the government in London fell. The new ministers wanted peace quickly and wanted the Americans’ goodwill. The article printed below is from the treaty they signed. It makes peace between subjects and citizens. The Crown’s allies are nowhere in it, and their homeland lay on the American side of the new line.

Staff colleges give a whole theme to this: war termination. How a war ends matters more than how it was fought, and the ending is made by those at the table. An ally’s leverage is highest while the fighting lasts and it is needed. It falls sharply once peace is in sight.

Now judge the Mohawk’s strategy by that test. In April 1779, while they were needed most, they had obtained from General Haldimand a written pledge to restore them. When the peace failed them, that paper was what they held. It was honoured in 1784, on the Grand River. The alliance did not save the valley, and nothing else would have. It did secure a written undertaking from the one power able to make it good, obtained at the moment of greatest leverage, and that undertaking is why there is a Nation on the Grand River to study the matter now.

The source

There shall be a firm and perpetual peace between his Britannic Majesty and the said states, and between the subjects of the one and the citizens of the other, wherefore all hostilities both by sea and land shall from henceforth cease.
The Definitive Treaty of Peace, Paris, 3 September 1783, article 7 (spelling modernised) · Between Great Britain and the United States of America. Read it for who is missing.

Key terms

War termination
How a war is brought to an end; who is at the table and what they settle.
Leverage
The power to obtain something because the other side needs you.
Oriskany
The battle of 6 August 1777 in which warriors of the Six Nations fought on both sides.
Refugee
A person driven from home by war.

Check yourself

1.Why was neutrality a weak choice for the Mohawk in 1775?
2.Who is missing from article 7 of the Treaty of Paris?
3.When is an ally’s leverage highest?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: War termination, Leverage, Oriskany, Refugee.