LIN 102
Evidence in practice: conflicts, old records and DNA
The working skills of proving a line: weighing a source, resolving records that disagree, reading the hands and dates of the eighteenth century, and knowing what DNA can and cannot show.
4 lessons14 hours12 questions
Begin the first lesson Sample certificateYou will be able to
- Classify a source, its information and the evidence it gives
- Resolve a conflict between two records in writing
- Transcribe an eighteenth-century entry and convert its date
- Say what a DNA test can and cannot prove about a line
The course in a short lecture
Lessons
- 01Weighing a source3 questions · with a primary source
- 02When records disagree3 questions · with a primary source
- 03Old records: hands, names and dates3 questions · with a primary source
- 04DNA, and exchanging a tree3 questions · with a primary source
Activities
| Young learners | Draw your family as far back as you know, and mark who told you each part. |
|---|---|
| Middle school | Copy an old entry letter for letter, then write what you think it says. |
| University | Classify five records for one link by source, information and evidence. |
| Law school | Write a resolution of a conflict between two records, to the standard the Register asks. |
Official description and materials
1.5 University credits · 14 learner hours · ≈ 0.5 ECTS. How credits work →
Official course descriptionCourse outlineTeacher’s guideSheet · Young learnersSheet · Middle schoolSheet · UniversitySheet · Law school
Read further
- Board for Certification of Genealogists, Genealogy Standards, 2nd ed. revised (2021)
- Elizabeth Shown Mills, Evidence Explained (Genealogical Publishing, current edition)
- The National Books: Proving Your Line (Book XXXVII)
- F.H. v. McDougall, 2008 SCC 53
- FamilySearch, GEDCOM 7 specification
At four levels
Ages 5 to 9
- Hear the story and colour it: Weighing a source
- Hear the story and colour it: When records disagree
- Hear the story and colour it: Old records: hands, names and dates
Grades 6 to 8
- Read a source and explain: Weighing a source
- Read a source and explain: When records disagree
- Read a source and explain: Old records: hands, names and dates
Undergraduate and up
- Analyse, with sources cited: Weighing a source
- Analyse, with sources cited: When records disagree
- Analyse, with sources cited: Old records: hands, names and dates
Law students and counsel
- Brief the law: Weighing a source
- Brief the law: When records disagree
- Brief the law: Old records: hands, names and dates
Standards
This course follows the University’s standards (set one): a Master Content Card, the universal competencies and a curriculum map. How the standards work →
Essential questions, rising in demand
- What is the difference between a source and the information in it?
- How is a conflict between records resolved?
- Say what a DNA test can and cannot prove about a line.
Claims and who contests them
- Claim. No DNA test identifies a nation; belonging is by a proved line or by adoption. Contested by: Testing companies sell ethnicity estimates that many people read as proof.
Curriculum map
| Level | Ontario and Canada | International level |
|---|---|---|
| Young learners | Ontario: Social Studies Gr 3, Strand A (family and community) | ISCED 1 (primary) |
| Middle school | Ontario: Gr 7 History, primary source evidence; historical thinking (historical significance · cause and consequence · continuity and change · historical perspective) | ISCED 2 (lower secondary) |
| Secondary | Ontario: CHI4U (Gr 12); IDC4U Interdisciplinary Studies (Gr 12) | ISCED 3 (upper secondary) |
| University | Ontario Undergraduate Degree Level Expectations; CMEC Canadian Degree Qualifications Framework | ISCED 6 (bachelor’s) |
| Law school | FLSC National Requirement; TRC Call to Action 28 | ISCED 7 (professional, J.D.) |
National: TRC Calls to Action 62–63; UELAC proof requirements (as a benchmark only). Global: BCG Genealogy Standards (2nd ed., 2019): the Genealogical Proof Standard; Evidence Explained citation form.