Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Study · Courses · Lineage

LIN 102

Evidence in practice: conflicts, old records and DNA

The working skills of proving a line: weighing a source, resolving records that disagree, reading the hands and dates of the eighteenth century, and knowing what DNA can and cannot show.

4 lessons14 hours12 questions

Begin the first lesson Sample certificate

You will be able to

  • Classify a source, its information and the evidence it gives
  • Resolve a conflict between two records in writing
  • Transcribe an eighteenth-century entry and convert its date
  • Say what a DNA test can and cannot prove about a line

The course in a short lecture

The video has no sound and starts only when you press play. Turn on captions to read each slide’s text. It shows what you will be able to do and, for each lesson, a question, its illustration and a key term. Everything in it is also on the lesson pages.

Lessons

  1. 01Weighing a source3 questions · with a primary source
  2. 02When records disagree3 questions · with a primary source
  3. 03Old records: hands, names and dates3 questions · with a primary source
  4. 04DNA, and exchanging a tree3 questions · with a primary source

Activities

Young learnersDraw your family as far back as you know, and mark who told you each part.
Middle schoolCopy an old entry letter for letter, then write what you think it says.
UniversityClassify five records for one link by source, information and evidence.
Law schoolWrite a resolution of a conflict between two records, to the standard the Register asks.

Official description and materials

1.5 University credits · 14 learner hours · ≈ 0.5 ECTS. How credits work →

Read further

  • Board for Certification of Genealogists, Genealogy Standards, 2nd ed. revised (2021)
  • Elizabeth Shown Mills, Evidence Explained (Genealogical Publishing, current edition)
  • The National Books: Proving Your Line (Book XXXVII)
  • F.H. v. McDougall, 2008 SCC 53
  • FamilySearch, GEDCOM 7 specification

At four levels

Undergraduate and up

  • Analyse, with sources cited: Weighing a source
  • Analyse, with sources cited: When records disagree
  • Analyse, with sources cited: Old records: hands, names and dates

Standards

This course follows the University’s standards (set one): a Master Content Card, the universal competencies and a curriculum map. How the standards work →

Essential questions, rising in demand

  1. What is the difference between a source and the information in it?
  2. How is a conflict between records resolved?
  3. Say what a DNA test can and cannot prove about a line.

Claims and who contests them

  • Claim. No DNA test identifies a nation; belonging is by a proved line or by adoption. Contested by: Testing companies sell ethnicity estimates that many people read as proof.

Curriculum map

LevelOntario and CanadaInternational level
Young learnersOntario: Social Studies Gr 3, Strand A (family and community)ISCED 1 (primary)
Middle schoolOntario: Gr 7 History, primary source evidence; historical thinking (historical significance · cause and consequence · continuity and change · historical perspective)ISCED 2 (lower secondary)
SecondaryOntario: CHI4U (Gr 12); IDC4U Interdisciplinary Studies (Gr 12)ISCED 3 (upper secondary)
UniversityOntario Undergraduate Degree Level Expectations; CMEC Canadian Degree Qualifications FrameworkISCED 6 (bachelor’s)
Law schoolFLSC National Requirement; TRC Call to Action 28ISCED 7 (professional, J.D.)

National: TRC Calls to Action 62–63; UELAC proof requirements (as a benchmark only). Global: BCG Genealogy Standards (2nd ed., 2019): the Genealogical Proof Standard; Evidence Explained citation form.