Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · LIN 102 Evidence in practice: conflicts, old records and DNA · Teacher’s guide

Teacher’s guide

Evidence in practice: conflicts, old records and DNA

A plan for every lesson in the six parts of the lesson model that Ontario’s colleges teach (bridge-in, objectives, pre-assessment, participatory learning, post-assessment, summary), with timings, a prompt, the common misreadings to watch for, the learning sheets at four levels and the rubric.

Learning sheets

Lesson plans

Lesson 1 · Weighing a source 60 minutes

5 minBridge-in. Open with the essential question: “What is the difference between a source and the information in it?”
5 minObjectives and pre-assessment. Put the lesson’s three questions on the board and take a show of hands on each
15 minThe lecture. Tell it; do not read it aloud. Stop at each key term, and show the illustration half-way
10 minParticipatory. In pairs, work the primary source: who made it, when, for whom, and what it says
10 minParticipatory. The activity at the class’s level
10 minPost-assessment. Self-check, then discuss the reason for each answer
5 minSummary. Return to the three questions; one sentence each on what changed in their thinking

Prompt: What is negative evidence?

  • Watch for: “An original record”. Someone’s conclusions from many sources.
  • Watch for: “Five”. Independence matters as much as number.
  • Watch for: “A bad copy”. In every list until 1779, and in none after.

Lesson 2 · When records disagree 60 minutes

5 minBridge-in. Open with the essential question: “What is the difference between a source and the information in it?”
5 minObjectives and pre-assessment. Put the lesson’s three questions on the board and take a show of hands on each
15 minThe lecture. Tell it; do not read it aloud. Stop at each key term, and show the illustration half-way
10 minParticipatory. In pairs, work the primary source: who made it, when, for whom, and what it says
10 minParticipatory. The activity at the class’s level
10 minPost-assessment. Self-check, then discuss the reason for each answer
5 minSummary. Return to the three questions; one sentence each on what changed in their thinking

Prompt: What if a conflict cannot be resolved?

  • Watch for: “Pick the older record”. Many conflicts vanish when the words are read again.
  • Watch for: “The longer one”. Original, disinterested, near in time.
  • Watch for: “Leave it out”. A conclusion that ignores a conflict is not proved.

Lesson 3 · Old records: hands, names and dates 60 minutes

5 minBridge-in. Open with the essential question: “What is the difference between a source and the information in it?”
5 minObjectives and pre-assessment. Put the lesson’s three questions on the board and take a show of hands on each
15 minThe lecture. Tell it; do not read it aloud. Stop at each key term, and show the illustration half-way
10 minParticipatory. In pairs, work the primary source: who made it, when, for whom, and what it says
10 minParticipatory. The activity at the class’s level
10 minPost-assessment. Self-check, then discuss the reason for each answer
5 minSummary. Return to the three questions; one sentence each on what changed in their thinking

Prompt: What comes before interpreting an entry?

  • Watch for: “In modern spelling”. Do not correct any.
  • Watch for: “1 January”. So 10 February 1740 is 1741 by our reckoning.
  • Watch for: “Deciding what it should say”. Keep an image with the transcript.

Lesson 4 · DNA, and exchanging a tree 60 minutes

5 minBridge-in. Open with the essential question: “What is the difference between a source and the information in it?”
5 minObjectives and pre-assessment. Put the lesson’s three questions on the board and take a show of hands on each
15 minThe lecture. Tell it; do not read it aloud. Stop at each key term, and show the illustration half-way
10 minParticipatory. In pairs, work the primary source: who made it, when, for whom, and what it says
10 minParticipatory. The activity at the class’s level
10 minPost-assessment. Self-check, then discuss the reason for each answer
5 minSummary. Return to the three questions; one sentence each on what changed in their thinking

Prompt: What does the Register ask of a family tree?

  • Watch for: “Yes, if mitochondrial”. A nation is a people with its own law of who belongs.
  • Watch for: “A substitute for documents”. The standards of 2019 say so.
  • Watch for: “Nothing; a tree is accepted”. A tree is a set of claims.

Rubric for the final task

CriterionLevel 3 · the standardLevel 4Level 2Level 1
Knowledge of the sourcesUses the instruments and readings accurately and fully, with no material error.Exact and complete, including what the sources do not say.Accurate with minor gaps.Frequent errors or missing sources.
Argument and analysisStates a clear thesis and supports it with evidence from the sources, weighing the main counter-reading.Original, and answers the strongest counter-reading.A thesis, thinly supported.No clear thesis.
CitationEvery source cited in Chicago notes and bibliography, so a reader can find each page.Flawless, including archival sources.Mostly complete; some lapses.Missing or unusable citations.
WritingClear, plain and organised; a reader follows it on one reading.Concise and memorable.Readable but uneven.Hard to follow.

All answers, with their reasons, are on the Teachers page.