Mohawk University · learning sheet · Law school

Evidence in practice: conflicts, old records and DNA

LIN 102 · back to the course

The problem

Advise on this claim: “No DNA test identifies a nation; belonging is by a proved line or by adoption.” It is contested: Testing companies sell ethnicity estimates that many people read as proof.

Authorities

  1. Board for Certification of Genealogists, Genealogy Standards, 2nd ed. revised (2021)
  2. Elizabeth Shown Mills, Evidence Explained (Genealogical Publishing, current edition)
  3. The National Books: Proving Your Line (Book XXXVII)
  4. F.H. v. McDougall, 2008 SCC 53
  5. FamilySearch, GEDCOM 7 specification

Brief (IRAC)

Briefing note

Marking guide

CriterionLevel 3 · the standard
IssueStates the legal question precisely.
RuleCites the governing instruments, statutes and cases correctly (McGill Guide).
ApplicationApplies the rule to the facts, both ways, and finds the weak point.
Conclusion and advocacyReaches a reasoned conclusion and argues it clearly in writing and orally.

Send to my teacher

Sending opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is kept by the University.