Courses · HIS 102 Doing history: sources, historians and oral history · Lesson 3 of 4
Historians and their debates
Lecture 3 of 4 · about 7 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- Why can two honest historians differ?
- What should you do when two accounts quarrel over one document?
- Does historiography mean all accounts are equal?
Two honest historians can read the same documents and tell different stories. The study of how history has been written, and why accounts differ, is called historiography. Until you have it, you will take the first book you read for the truth.
Accounts differ for four reasons. Historians ask different questions: one wants to know how a colony was governed, another how a people kept its land. They use different sources: one works from the Colonial Office’s files, another from council minutes and family memory. They write at different times, and each generation notices what the last ignored. And they stand in different places. A descendant of settlers, an officer of the Crown and a member of the Nation will not find the same things remarkable.
The writing on the Grand River shows all four. In 1838 William Stone published a life of Joseph Brant in two volumes, admiring and romantic, written from papers the family lent him. For more than a century it was the standard account. In 1964 Charles Johnston edited The Valley of the Six Nations, a collection of documents that is still where most students begin; its selection and its introduction see the Tract largely through the eyes of the officials who administered it. Barbara Graymont’s study of the Iroquois in the American Revolution, in 1972, and Isabel Kelsay’s life of Brant, in 1984, rebuilt the story from far more sources. In 2006 Alan Taylor’s The Divided Ground set Brant’s land dealings in the politics of a new border. And in 2017 Susan Hill’s The Clay We Are Made Of told the history of the Grand River lands from Haudenosaunee sources and ideas of land.
They disagree on things that matter. Was the Proclamation of 1784 a grant of the land outright, a licence to occupy it, or the setting apart of a reserve? Did Brant’s sales and leases defend the people’s future by raising an income, or begin the loss of the Tract? For whom was the land set apart? The Nation has its own answers, and they are one position among these. A student should know where each answer comes from.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Historiography” means. Then read on.
To read a historian well, ask five questions. What is the thesis, in one sentence? What sources is it built on, and whose voices are missing from them? When was it written, and what was being argued about at that time? Where does the author stand, and do they say so? And what would a reader who disagreed point to?
Then read two against each other on one question. Set out what each claims, what each cites, and whether they are in fact disagreeing or answering different questions. Often the quarrel turns on a single document read two ways. Go and read that document.
Historiography does not mean that all accounts are equal. Some rest on more evidence, read it more carefully, and admit what tells against them. Those are better histories, whoever wrote them.
Thucydides, the first historian to explain his method, wrote the sentence printed below. He expected to be less entertaining than the storytellers and hoped to be more useful. It is still the standard.
The source
The absence of romance in my history will, I fear, detract somewhat from its interest; but if it be judged useful by those inquirers who desire an exact knowledge of the past as an aid to the interpretation of the future, which in the course of human things must resemble if it does not reflect it, I shall be content.Thucydides, History of the Peloponnesian War, book 1, chapter 22 · Translated by Richard Crawley, 1874.
Key terms
- Historiography
- The study of how history has been written and why accounts differ.
- Thesis
- A historian’s main claim, which the book or article argues for.
- Standpoint
- Where an author stands in relation to the events described.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Historiography, Thesis, Standpoint.