Courses · HIS 102 Doing history: sources, historians and oral history · Lesson 1 of 4
Sources and the archive
Lecture 1 of 4 · about 7 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- What makes a source primary?
- Why do archives keep records in their creator’s order?
- What do you record before reading further?
History is an argument from evidence about what happened. This course teaches how that work is done. Its examples come from the Nation’s own past, and its methods are those of the discipline everywhere.
Evidence comes in two kinds. A primary source was made at the time by someone who took part or saw: a proclamation, a letter, a register of baptisms, a map, a belt, a newspaper of the day. A secondary source is a later account built from primary ones: a history book, an article, this lesson. The distinction is about use. A history written in 1838 is a secondary source for the war of 1775 and a primary source for what people believed in 1838.
Every source has to be questioned before it is believed. Ask five things. Who made it, and how did they know? When, and how long after the event? For whom, and what did the maker want that reader to think or do? What does it actually say, as distinct from what you expected it to say? And what does it leave out? The Pledge of 1779, printed below, repays the exercise. A general writes, in wartime, to allies he needs, and puts in writing a promise his predecessor made by word of mouth. Each of those facts tells you something about how to read it.
Note the silences. The records of the eighteenth century were mostly written by officers, clergy and clerks, in English, French or Dutch. Mohawk speech reaches us through interpreters and secretaries. Women appear rarely, though they held the land and named the chiefs. What the record does not say is evidence too, about the record.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Primary source” means. Then read on.
Most primary sources live in archives. An archive keeps records in the order their creator kept them, in groups called fonds, because the arrangement is part of the meaning. You do not browse an archive by subject. You read a finding aid, a description of what a fonds holds, and ask for a box, a volume or a reel by its reference.
The records of the Grand River are scattered, and knowing where is half the work. The papers of Governor Haldimand are in the British Library, with copies at Library and Archives Canada. The Colonial Office’s correspondence with Canada is in the National Archives at Kew. The records of the Indian Department, including a great deal on the Six Nations, are at Library and Archives Canada in the group called RG 10. The Archives of Ontario holds Simcoe’s papers and the land records of the province. Church registers of the Mohawk Valley survive in several hands. Many of these are now digitised and free to read.
When you find a document, record four things before you read another word: the repository, the collection, the reference, and the page or folio. A source you cannot find again is a source you cannot use.
The Nation keeps its own instruments in its Register with certified extracts, so that its record is no longer left for others to keep. The habit this lesson teaches is the same one: know where a thing came from, and be able to show it.
The source
By His Excellency General Haldimand, Esq., Captain General and Commander-in-Chief of the Province of Quebec, and upon the frontiers of Quebec, etc. Some of the Mohawks of the Villages of Canojaharie, Tikondarago, and Aughugo, whose settlements than had been on account of their steady attachment to the King’s service and the interests of Government ruined by the rebels; having informed me that my predecessor, Sir Guy Carleton, was pleased to promise, as soon as the present troubles were at an end, the same should be restored at the expense of the Government, to the state they were in before the wars broke out, and said promise appearing to me just, I do hereby ratify the same and assure them the said promise, so far as in me lies, shall be faithfully executed, as soon as that happy time comes. GIVEN UNDER MY HAND AND SEAL at Quebec the 7th day of April, 1779. Signed: FRED HALDIMANDThe Haldimand Pledge, 7 April 1779: a document to question · Given at Quebec; signed Fred. Haldimand.
Key terms
- Primary source
- A record made at the time by someone who took part or saw.
- Secondary source
- A later account built from primary sources.
- Fonds
- The whole body of records made by one person or office, kept in its original order.
- Finding aid
- A description of what an archival collection holds and how to ask for it.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Primary source, Secondary source, Fonds, Finding aid.