Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · HIS 301 The Mohawk Chapel and the stone of 1984 · Lesson 3 of 4

Whose chapel?

Lecture 3 of 4 · about 6 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. How does the Nation describe the Chapel?
  2. A chapel of ease serves…
  3. How should a learner treat the two descriptions?

The Nation holds that the Chapel is a free chapel of the Crown with exempt jurisdiction, in which the Mohawk prerogative runs and which no denomination should own; its keepers call it a chapel of ease.

Weigh the two descriptions as a historian would: what each term means, which records use which, and what follows from each.

The terms come from English church law. Most churches belong to a parish and answer to a bishop. A chapel of ease is a second building within a parish, put up for the ease of parishioners who live far from the parish church; it has no standing of its own.

A royal peculiar, or free chapel of the Crown, is different in kind. It belongs to the Sovereign and is exempt from the bishop’s jurisdiction; Westminster Abbey and St George’s Chapel at Windsor are the best-known examples. A Chapel Royal is an establishment of the Sovereign’s own household.

Two descriptions of the Chapel. Compare whose it would be, and who would decide, under each.
A free chapel of the CrownBelongs to the SovereignExempt from the bishopThe Mohawk prerogative runs in itNo denomination owns itA chapel of easeBelongs to a parishUnder the bishopManaged by the local churchA second building, with no standing of itsown

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Free chapel” means. Then read on.

The Nation holds that the Mohawk Chapel is of this second kind: built by the Crown for its allies, styled by the King in 1904, and so standing outside the ordinary structure of any denomination. On that view the Mohawk prerogative runs in it, and no church body should own it.

Those who keep the Chapel have described it as a chapel of ease, which would place it under the local church. The two descriptions cannot both be right, and a great deal follows from the difference, including who decides how the Chapel is used and who may be buried in its yard.

This is a question you can research. Look for the instrument of 1904 and its wording; the deeds, if any, by which the land is held; and how the Chapel has described itself over time. State what each source says before you say which description it supports.

Neither description should be accepted on anyone’s say-so, including this University’s. The Nation states its reading and gives its reasons: the Crown built the Chapel, the King named it, and it has stood from the first for the alliance between the Mohawk and the Crown. Those who hold the other view have reasons too, in how the Chapel has been staffed and maintained. A good essay sets the two side by side, document by document, and then says which the evidence favours, and what further document, if it could be found, would settle it. Keep an open mind until you have read them.

Key terms

Free chapel
A chapel exempt from the bishop’s jurisdiction, under the Crown.
Chapel of ease
A chapel serving a parish, under its church.
Royal peculiar
A church belonging to the Sovereign, exempt from the bishop.

Check yourself

1.How does the Nation describe the Chapel?
2.A chapel of ease serves…
3.How should a learner treat the two descriptions?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Free chapel, Chapel of ease, Royal peculiar.