Courses · LAW 201 Sections 109 and 52 · Lesson 4 of 4
Three cases to know
Lecture 4 of 4 · about 6 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- In St Catherine’s Milling, what completed the province’s title?
- What did Seybold decide about surrendered land?
- On which instrument did the Court rely in Isaac v Davey?
Three decisions shape every argument about the Tract, and a student should be able to state each in a paragraph.
St Catherine’s Milling and Lumber Co v The Queen (1888). A lumber company held a federal licence to cut timber on land in Ontario that the Ojibway had surrendered by treaty. Ontario said the timber was the province’s. The Privy Council agreed. Under section 109 the province held the underlying title all along, burdened by the Indian interest, which Lord Watson called “a personal and usufructuary right”; on surrender the burden fell away and the province’s title was complete. The lesson the Nation takes: an interest that burdens provincial title under section 109 is ended by surrender, and by nothing less.
Ontario Mining Co v Seybold (1903). After a surrender, the federal government set apart a reserve from the surrendered land and later sold part of it. The Privy Council held the sale passed nothing: once surrendered, the land was Ontario’s, and Canada could not create a reserve out of it without the province. The lesson: after a surrender there is no interest left from which anything further can be given. The Nation applies this to lands the Six Nations are said to have surrendered in the 1840s, and asks how any later reserve could have been made within them.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Usufructuary right” means. Then read on.
Isaac v Davey (1977). Supporters of the hereditary council at Six Nations barred the elected council from the council house. The Supreme Court of Canada held that the lands were a “reserve” within the Indian Act, so the Act’s elected council governed. To reach that result the Court relied on the Simcoe Patent of 1793 as the instrument under which the land was held. The Nation’s criticism is direct: the Patent was refused by the Mohawk, and the Court treated a refused instrument as the root of title without deciding what the Proclamation of 1784 had already given.
Read together, the first two cases supply the Nation’s rule and the third its grievance. The rule is that only surrender ends the interest. The grievance is that the courts have looked at the Tract through the wrong instrument.
A fair student will also state the other side. In Isaac v Davey the Court decided the case on the Act’s definition of a reserve and did not rule on the full nature of the 1784 grant. Whether the Proclamation created a legal interest of the kind the Nation describes has not been decided by the Supreme Court. That question is open, which is a reason to study it closely.
The source
The existing aboriginal and treaty rights of the aboriginal peoples of Canada are hereby recognized and affirmed.Constitution Act, 1982, s. 35(1) · Part II of the Constitution Act, 1982: the other road.
Key terms
- Usufructuary right
- A right to use and take the fruits of land owned by another.
- Underlying title
- The Crown’s ultimate title, held by the province under s. 109.
- Root of title
- The instrument from which a title is traced.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Usufructuary right, Underlying title, Root of title.