Courses · LAW 201 Sections 109 and 52 · Lesson 3 of 4
Two roads
Lecture 3 of 4 · about 6 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- Which road does the Nation take?
- On the Nation’s reading, what alone removes the interest?
- Why does the Nation say no surrender is possible?
The Six Nations’ case argues exclusive use and occupation, collectively, under section 35. The Nation holds the Mohawk class has exclusive use and enjoyment, individually and by inheritance, under sections 109 and 52.
The Nation warns that the s. 35 road would fold the hereditary class into a band whose list has no certainty of posterity, with a release signed for all. It relies on St Catherine’s Milling for the rule that only a surrender removes the interest, and notes that no Mohawk surrender was ever made, nor could be by a posterity that includes the unborn.
The two roads start from different sections and never meet. Section 35 recognises and affirms existing Aboriginal and treaty rights. The rights are held by Aboriginal peoples as collectives, they can be limited where the Crown justifies the limit, and the usual way they are honoured is the duty to consult.
The road through sections 109 and 52 starts from property. The interest is whatever the grant gave. It is held by the persons the grant names, and it is protected as part of the constitutional settlement of 1867. Nothing on this road asks whether a limit is justified; the question is only whether a law is inconsistent with the Constitution.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Surrender” means. Then read on.
The Nation’s warning about the first road is practical. A section 35 settlement is made with a collective, and in practice with a band. A band’s list is governed by membership codes and by the Indian Act: people can transfer in from other communities, and the list offers no certainty that those on it descend from the class. When a release is signed, it is signed for everyone.
Then section 88 of the Indian Act does its work: provincial laws apply to “Indians” by federal incorporation. Once the class is treated as a band, the Nation says, the gate is open, and it does not close again.
St Catherine’s Milling and Ontario Mining Co v Seybold (1903) show why surrender is the hinge. In both, the province’s title became complete only on surrender; in Seybold, once the land was surrendered there was no Indian interest left from which a reserve could be made without the province. A surrender ends the matter. The Nation’s reply is that the Mohawk class has never made one, and that a class which includes the unborn cannot.
Neither road is free of risk, and a student should be able to argue both. The first has decades of case law behind it. The second rests on a reading of section 109 that the courts have not yet been asked to apply to a grant of this kind.
Key terms
- Surrender
- Giving up an interest to the Crown.
- Section 35
- Recognises and affirms existing Aboriginal and treaty rights.
- Release
- A giving up of claims, signed as part of a settlement.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Surrender, Section 35, Release.