Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · LAW 201 Sections 109 and 52 · Lesson 1 of 4

Section 109

Lecture 1 of 4 · about 6 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. Which clause of s. 109 does the Nation rely on?
  2. Why not the trust clause?
  3. In s. 109, the provinces took their lands subject to…

At Confederation the provinces took their lands subject to two things: any trusts, and any interest other than that of the province. The Nation places the Mohawk interest in the second clause, never the first, because a trust would bring it under the Indian Act.

On that reading Ontario took the Tract encumbered by the interest: what the Nation calls a latent defect in title, cured only by a surrender the class has never made.

Read the section slowly; its grammar does the work. The lands “shall belong to the several Provinces”, and then come two limits, joined by “and”: “subject to any Trusts existing in respect thereof, and to any Interest other than that of the Province in the same”. Two different things are preserved. A trust has a trustee who holds for another. An interest is simply a right in the land that belongs to someone else.

In St Catherine’s Milling (1888) the Privy Council applied the second limit to Indian title. It held that the province took the underlying title at Confederation, burdened by the Indian interest, and that the province’s title became full only when that interest was surrendered. The burden travelled with the land.

Read from the top down. Each layer rests on the one above; the burden on the land passes down with it.
1784: the grantThe Crown gives the Tract to the class and their posterity.1867: section 109Ontario takes its lands “subject to … any Interest other than that of the Province”.Today: every title under the ProvincePatents, deeds and by-laws all derive from what the Province took.

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Latent defect” means. Then read on.

The Nation takes the same structure and applies it to the grant of 1784. Before Confederation the Crown had given the Tract to the class. Whatever Ontario took in 1867, it took subject to that. And since, on the Nation’s account, the class has never surrendered, the burden has never been lifted.

That is the latent defect. A buyer who searches title in the land registry finds a chain of deeds back to a Crown patent and stops there. The defect lies behind the patent, in what the Crown had left to grant. It does not appear on the face of the register, which is what “latent” means.

Why not call it a trust and be done? Because a trust would make the Crown the holder and the class its beneficiaries, and the Indian Act is the statute by which the Crown manages lands it holds for “Indians”. The Nation’s whole position is that the class holds directly. It chooses the second limb of section 109 for that reason, and uses the word with care.

The opposing view should be stated fairly. It holds that any interest the Mohawk received in 1784 was given up by later surrenders or absorbed into the reserve, so that nothing remained for section 109 to preserve. The answer depends on facts, on who surrendered what, and that is why the record matters so much.

The source

All Lands, Mines, Minerals, and Royalties belonging to the several Provinces of Canada, Nova Scotia, and New Brunswick at the Union […] shall belong to the several Provinces of Ontario, Quebec, Nova Scotia, and New Brunswick in which the same are situate or arise, subject to any Trusts existing in respect thereof, and to any Interest other than that of the Province in the same.
Constitution Act, 1867, s. 109 · 30 & 31 Vict, c 3 (UK).

Key terms

Encumbrance
Another’s interest burdening land.
Latent defect
A flaw in title not visible on its face.
Trust
Property held by one person for the benefit of another.

Check yourself

1.Which clause of s. 109 does the Nation rely on?
2.Why not the trust clause?
3.In s. 109, the provinces took their lands subject to…

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Encumbrance, Latent defect, Trust.