Courses · FAC 107 Teaching online: quality criteria · Lesson 4 of 4
Community and care at a distance
Lecture 4 of 4 · about 7 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- What makes a good discussion prompt?
- Should cameras be required?
- What should you do when a learner goes quiet?
A learner in a classroom who is struggling can be seen. Online, the struggling learner simply goes quiet, and nobody notices until they are gone. Teaching at a distance means doing on purpose what a classroom does by accident.
Start with discussion, since it is where community is made or lost. A prompt that asks for an opinion gets thirty opinions and no conversation. A good prompt gives learners something to do with a source and asks for a conclusion: “Read the two passages. Which reading does the second support? Quote the words you rely on.” Ask each learner to answer one other person, by adding evidence or raising an objection, and not by agreeing. Take part yourself, but late and lightly. If the instructor answers every post, learners write for the instructor and stop reading one another. Close each discussion with a summary that names who said what.
In video sessions, make it easy to take part and safe not to be seen. Do not require cameras. People join from kitchens, cars and shared rooms, and a person’s home is their own. Use the chat, polls and small groups so that there is more than one way to speak. Ask before recording, say who will be able to see the recording and for how long, and let anyone who objects take part in another way.
Notice absence. Check once a week who has not appeared. Write to them privately the same week, briefly and without reproach: “I noticed you weren’t in this week’s discussion. Is everything all right? Is there anything that would help?” Most learners who leave online courses say afterwards that nobody seemed to notice. Often a small thing was in the way: a broken link, a missed week they were ashamed to mention, an emergency. One message brings many of them back.
Keep the rules of the room online, and add two. Nothing a learner writes in a class space is copied outside it without their leave. And disagreement is with the argument: tone carries badly in text, so ask people to read a post twice before answering in anger.
Integrity online needs no surveillance. Software that watches learners through their cameras is intrusive, unreliable and a barrier to people with disabilities and poor connections, and the University does not use it. Assess by work that is hard to fake: tasks on particular sources, drafts, and a short conversation about a finished piece.
Look after privacy. Use the University’s own channels for anything about marks or personal matters. Do not move a class onto a commercial platform that learners must join with their own accounts without telling them what it collects.
And remember who is on the other end. The article printed below speaks of people living outside their communities and their access to education in their own culture. For such a learner, a reply from an instructor who knows their name is the University. Nothing else in a course is as easy to give or matters as much.
The source
States shall, in conjunction with indigenous peoples, take effective measures, in order for indigenous individuals, particularly children, including those living outside their communities, to have access, when possible, to an education in their own culture and provided in their own language.United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, article 14(3) · UN General Assembly resolution 61/295, 13 September 2007.
Key terms
- Discussion prompt
- The question that starts an online discussion; a good one asks for a conclusion from a source.
- Outreach
- Writing privately to a learner who has gone quiet.
- Proctoring software
- Programs that watch learners during tests; the University does not use them.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Discussion prompt, Outreach, Proctoring software.