Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · FAC 107 Teaching online: quality criteria · Lesson 1 of 4

Three presences

Lecture 1 of 4 · about 6 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. What is the commonest failure of an online course?
  2. Where do online discussions often stall?
  3. What builds social presence?

Most of this University’s teaching happens on a screen, and most of its learners will never meet their instructor in person. A course online does not teach itself. The commonest failure is a set of good pages with nobody there.

In 2000 three Canadian researchers at the University of Alberta, Randy Garrison, Terry Anderson and Walter Archer, described what a course at a distance needs. They called their model the Community of Inquiry, and it names three kinds of presence.

Teaching presence is the visible work of the instructor. It has three parts: design, done before the course opens; facilitation, which is guiding discussion and keeping it moving; and direct instruction, which is explaining, correcting and giving feedback. Learners should feel that someone is running the course. A weekly note, a prompt answer and comments on work are how they come to feel it.

Social presence is the sense that the other people are real. Learners will not risk a half-formed idea in front of names on a list. It is built deliberately. Introduce yourself in your own voice, with something of who you are. Ask learners to introduce themselves in the first week, and answer each one. Use names. Allow some conversation that is not about the course. In a University whose members are scattered across the world, this is part of the purpose: for some learners the class is the first company of their own people they have kept.

Three cards, one for each presence. Read each from the top: the presence, what it is, and one way to build it.
Teaching presenceSomeone is visibly runningthe course.A note each week; promptanswersSocial presenceThe other people are real.Introductions; names; a replyto eachCognitive presenceLearners build meaningtogether.Ask for a conclusion, notopinions

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Teaching presence” means. Then read on.

Cognitive presence is the thinking itself: the extent to which learners build meaning by working on a problem together. The model describes it in four phases. Something puzzling sets the inquiry off. Learners explore, gathering information and ideas. They integrate, connecting the ideas into an explanation. And they resolve, by testing the explanation on a case. Online discussions often stall at exploration, with everyone sharing and nobody concluding. It is the instructor’s job to push toward the last two phases: “so what follows?”, “which of these two readings does the source support?”

The three depend on one another. Without social presence people will not think aloud. Without teaching presence the thinking wanders. Without cognitive presence the course is a pleasant club.

You can check a course for all three in ten minutes. Is there a welcome from a person? Does each week open with a note from the instructor? Is there a place where learners talk to one another, and has the instructor been in it in the last few days? Does each discussion ask for a conclusion? Has every piece of submitted work been answered?

The University’s lesson pages supply a good deal of the design. They cannot supply you. The Universal Declaration, in the sentence printed below, says what education is for, and it is not something a page can do alone.

The source

Education shall be directed to the full development of the human personality and to the strengthening of respect for human rights and fundamental freedoms.
Universal Declaration of Human Rights, article 26(2) · UN General Assembly resolution 217 A (III), 10 December 1948.

Key terms

Teaching presence
The visible work of the instructor: design, facilitation and direct instruction.
Social presence
Learners’ sense that the other people in a course are real.
Cognitive presence
The building of meaning through shared inquiry.
Community of Inquiry
A model of online learning built on the three presences.

Check yourself

1.What is the commonest failure of an online course?
2.Where do online discussions often stall?
3.What builds social presence?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Teaching presence, Social presence, Cognitive presence, Community of Inquiry.