Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · FAC 107 Teaching online: quality criteria · Lesson 2 of 4

Quality criteria

Lecture 2 of 4 · about 7 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. How many general standards has the Quality Matters rubric?
  2. When should a course be reviewed?
  3. What can quality criteria not measure?

Colleges now ask their faculty to learn the criteria by which an online course is judged, before they build or teach one. Several sets exist. The best known in North America is the Quality Matters rubric for higher education, first published in 2003 and revised regularly since. It is a fair model of them all.

The rubric has eight general standards. The first is the course overview and introduction: can a learner tell, on arriving, how to begin and what is expected? The second is learning objectives: are they stated, measurable and written for the learner? The third is assessment and measurement: do the assessments measure the objectives, and are the criteria known? The fourth is instructional materials: do they serve the objectives, and are they current and properly cited? The fifth is learning activities and learner interaction. The sixth is course technology. The seventh is learner support: does the course say where to get help? The eighth is accessibility and usability.

One idea runs through the rubric, and you met it in FAC 102: alignment. The objectives, the assessments, the materials, the activities and the technology must all support one another. A reviewer traces each objective through the course to see that it is taught, practised and assessed. A course can look handsome and fail on alignment, and it can look plain and pass.

Three features of the method are worth copying. A course is reviewed before it opens, when faults can still be fixed. It is reviewed by peers, other instructors trained in the rubric, and not by a manager. And the review is of the design, and not of the instructor: its result is a list of specific improvements.

The table lists the eight standards. Read across: the standard, and the question a reviewer asks.
StandardThe reviewer asksCourse overviewCan a learner tell how to begin?Learning objectivesAre they stated and measurable?AssessmentDoes it measure the objectives?MaterialsDo they serve the objectives?Activities and interactionDo learners practise and meet?TechnologyDo the tools help?Learner supportIs help signposted?Accessibility and usabilityCan everyone use it?

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Alignment” means. Then read on.

This University applies the same thinking in public. Its course structure sets out what every course must have. An audit measures each course against it from the course’s own data and prints the score. Every faculty is set beside an outside benchmark, with what the comparison shows it lacks. An instructor can therefore see, before teaching a course, exactly where it falls short.

The University’s rule on video, printed below, is one quality criterion stated plainly. It combines three things a reviewer would look for: the learner controls the pace, nothing depends on sound or sight alone, and the same content is available in another form.

To use the criteria on a course of your own, do a short review with a colleague. Each of you goes through the other’s course as a new learner would, on a phone, for half an hour, with the eight standards beside you. Note where you were lost, where a link failed, where you could not tell what was wanted, and where an outcome was never practised. Then exchange notes. It is uncomfortable for about five minutes and useful for a year.

One caution. Criteria of this kind measure design. They cannot measure whether a course is true, or whether its instructor is present and kind. A course could pass every standard and teach something false. Quality criteria are a floor to build on, and the judgment of what is taught rests with the faculty.

The source

A video must not start by itself, and whatever it shows must also be given in text.
The University’s rule on video · Draft Directive on the University’s standards and credits; proposed, for adoption by the Gazette.

Key terms

Quality criteria
Published standards by which the design of an online course is judged.
Peer review
Review of a course by fellow instructors trained in the criteria.
Alignment
Objectives, assessments, materials and activities all supporting one another.

Check yourself

1.How many general standards has the Quality Matters rubric?
2.When should a course be reviewed?
3.What can quality criteria not measure?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Quality criteria, Peer review, Alignment.