Courses · DIP 301 Recognition and relations: the Nation’s aims · Lesson 3 of 4
The Nation’s aspiration
Lecture 3 of 4 · about 7 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- Does the Nation claim today to be recognised as a state?
- What is the Nation’s long-term aim?
- What is the first aim for the bills?
This lesson states what the Mohawk Nation of Grand River seeks, as the Nation has stated it, and then asks you to examine it as you would any nation’s aims. Be exact about three things: what is claimed today, what is aimed at in the long term, and what others contest.
Begin with the present position, which is printed below in the Nation’s own words. The Nation does not claim to be recognised as a state. It records its own acts, issues its own documents and deals with the Crown directly. Whether another government, bank or institution relies on its documents is that other’s decision, and the Register records what they decide.
Next, the footing. The Nation stands on four instruments of the Crown: the Pledge of 1779, the Proclamation of 1784, the Order in Council of 1789 and the register of 1796. Its relationship is nation to Crown, the Mohawk and the King directly. It does not speak for the Confederacy or for any other Mohawk community, and none of them speaks for it. It does not dispute the King’s sovereignty in Canadian society. The authority it asserts is within its own order, over its own people and the territory the instruments set apart.
Now the long-term aim. It is for the Mohawk Nation of Grand River to have a state of its own: its own economy, its own airports and shipping docks, and its own borders. Set that beside the Montevideo tests. The population is the class the instruments name, and the Register exists to show who they are. The territory is the Tract, six miles deep on each side of the river. The government is the Secretariat and its offices, which keep a Gazette, a Register, a Treasury and a press. The capacity to enter into relations is what this faculty teaches.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Nation to Crown” means. Then read on.
Between the present and that aim the Nation has set a nearer step. It has drafted bills for the Legislature of Ontario, for the House of Commons and for the Senate, and published them. They do not ask for a gift of land. They ask each legislature to honour section 109 and the interest of 1784, to name the Nation as the body through which the holders of that interest act, and to provide for an orderly handing over of powers on the Tract to the Nation’s own systems and officers. Crown land no longer needed would return to the Nation. No private owner is dispossessed. The first aim is modest: to have the bills introduced and read a first time, so that they stand on the parliamentary record.
Test this with the tools of the faculty. In the war-college model, the end is a state, and the bills are a way of gaining an intermediate end that adds to the means. In Sun Tzu’s terms, they address plans and alliances and leave the cities alone, since nobody’s house is at stake. In Kautilya’s terms, the Nation seeks the shelter of the sovereign whose own instruments are engaged. Among the models of the last lesson, the nation-to-Crown relationship most resembles that of a Crown Dependency, though the aim goes further.
Then state the contest fairly. Canada and Ontario have not accepted the Nation’s reading of the instruments, and no court has ordered it. The elected council of the Six Nations asserts that it alone speaks for the Tract. Many who live on the Tract have never heard of the interest. No bill has yet been introduced. And the distance between the means and the end is, on any honest view, very great. A student should be able to say all of this, and also to say what would count as progress. That is the subject of the last lesson.
The source
No. It records its acts, issues its documents and deals with the Crown directly; whether others rely on them is theirs to decide, and the Register records what they decide.Recognition and Relations: “Does the Nation claim to be recognised as a state?” · Recognition and Relations, Book V of the National Books (first edition, October 2026), section 15.
Key terms
- Aspiration
- A long-term aim, as distinct from a present claim.
- Nation to Crown
- The Nation’s relationship: the Mohawk and the King directly.
- First reading
- The formal introduction of a bill in a legislature, which places it on the record.
- Intermediate end
- A nearer goal that, once gained, adds to the means for the next.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Aspiration, Nation to Crown, First reading, Intermediate end.