Courses · DIP 301 Recognition and relations: the Nation’s aims · Lesson 2 of 4
Small sovereignties and other models
Lecture 2 of 4 · about 7 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- What do the Crown Dependencies show?
- What does the Order of Malta lack?
- Which question matters most when comparing the models?
Full membership of the United Nations is one way for a people to govern itself. It is not the only way, and for small nations it has seldom been the first step. This lesson surveys five models that exist in the world today. Each is a real arrangement that people live under, and a student of the Nation’s aims should be able to compare them.
The first is the small state. Liechtenstein has about forty thousand people, Monaco fewer, San Marino fewer still. Each is a member of the United Nations and each leans on a larger neighbour for defence, currency or customs, by treaty. Andorra has two princes, one of whom is the president of France. These states show that sovereignty and reliance on a neighbour can sit together, if the terms are written down.
The second is sovereignty without territory. The Sovereign Order of Malta lost its island in 1798. It has no land beyond two buildings in Rome, and it exchanges ambassadors with more than a hundred states, holds observer status at the United Nations and issues its own passports and stamps. The Holy See carried on diplomatic relations for nearly sixty years with no territory at all. Both show that standing can rest on history, purpose and conduct.
The third is free association. The Cook Islands and Niue govern themselves entirely and make their own treaties, while their people are citizens of New Zealand, which helps with defence when asked. Palau, the Marshall Islands and Micronesia have compacts of a similar kind with the United States and are members of the United Nations as well. The arrangement can be ended by the smaller party.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Free association” means. Then read on.
The fourth is the one closest to home for a people whose relationship is with the Crown. Jersey, Guernsey and the Isle of Man are the Crown Dependencies. They are not part of the United Kingdom and are not represented in its Parliament. They have their own legislatures, courts, laws and taxes. Their allegiance is to the Crown directly. The United Kingdom’s government looks after their defence and international relations on the Crown’s behalf, and by convention its Parliament does not legislate for them without their consent. The Channel Islands have stood in that relationship since 1204. They are the working example of a people under the same sovereign as a larger country without being under that country’s parliament.
The fifth is autonomy within a state. The Åland Islands are part of Finland with their own language, flag and law-making power, under a settlement of 1921 that the League of Nations made. Greenland has governed itself within the Danish realm since 2009, with an acknowledged right to choose independence. In Canada, Nunavut was created in 1999, and the Nisga’a treaty of 2000 set up a government with law-making power of its own. The article printed below states the principle as the United Nations Declaration puts it.
Compare the five on four questions. Where does the people’s authority come from: its own history, a treaty, or a grant that could be withdrawn? Who conducts its foreign relations? Whose courts have the last word? And can the arrangement be changed without the smaller party’s consent? The answers differ a great deal, and the last question matters most.
None of these is a pattern to be copied. Each grew from its own history, as any arrangement for the Grand River must. They are here so that when the Nation’s aims are stated in the next lesson, you can place them among arrangements that already work in the world.
The source
Indigenous peoples, in exercising their right to self-determination, have the right to autonomy or self-government in matters relating to their internal and local affairs, as well as ways and means for financing their autonomous functions.United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, article 4 · UN General Assembly resolution 61/295, 13 September 2007.
Key terms
- Crown Dependency
- Jersey, Guernsey and the Isle of Man: self-governing, under the Crown, and not part of the United Kingdom.
- Free association
- Full self-government in a chosen partnership with a larger state, which the smaller party may end.
- Autonomy
- Self-government in internal affairs within a larger state.
- Observer status
- A place at an international body without a vote.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Crown Dependency, Free association, Autonomy, Observer status.