Courses · DIP 301 Recognition and relations: the Nation’s aims · Lesson 1 of 4
What makes a state, and who decides
Lecture 1 of 4 · about 7 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- Which is one of the four Montevideo qualifications?
- What does the declaratory theory hold?
- How does recognition come in practice?
The usual definition of a state in international law comes from a treaty among the countries of the Americas, signed at Montevideo in 1933 and printed below. It gives four qualifications: a permanent population, a defined territory, a government, and the capacity to enter into relations with other states. The definition is short, and each part has been argued over ever since.
A population need not be large. Tuvalu and Nauru each have fewer than fifteen thousand people and are members of the United Nations. A territory need not be large or even fully agreed: many states have disputed borders. A government must be effective, which means it actually governs. The fourth qualification is the subtle one. It is about independence: whether the body acts for itself in its dealings with others or through someone else.
Then comes the question the same article 3 raises. Does a state exist because it meets the tests, or because other states say it does? There are two theories. On the declaratory theory, which Montevideo adopts, a state exists as a matter of fact once it has the four qualifications, and recognition by others only declares what is already so. On the constitutive theory, a state becomes a state in law when others recognise it, and not before.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Declaratory theory” means. Then read on.
Practice lies between the two. Recognition is a political act that each state decides for itself, for its own reasons. There is no world authority that confers statehood. Membership of the United Nations is the nearest thing to a general acknowledgment, and under article 4 of the Charter it requires a recommendation of the Security Council, where five powers hold a veto, and then a vote of the General Assembly. So there are bodies that meet the Montevideo tests and are recognised by few, and others recognised by many that lack control of their territory. Kosovo is recognised by about half the world’s states. Palestine is recognised by most and has been an observer state at the United Nations since 2012. Taiwan governs itself fully and is recognised by a handful. Somaliland has governed itself since 1991 and for decades was recognised by none.
Three things follow for the student. First, statehood is not all or nothing in practice. There are degrees and kinds of standing, and the next lesson surveys them. Second, recognition comes one relationship at a time. It is built from particular acts: a letter answered, a document accepted, an agreement kept. Third, what a body does counts for more than what it declares. The fourth qualification is shown by actually conducting relations, properly and over time.
This is why the Nation’s book on the subject is called Recognition and Relations, and why its first rule is that recognition is recorded and never assumed. The Nation does not announce that it is recognised. It keeps a register of each occasion on which another government, bank or border has relied on one of its documents, and of each occasion on which one has refused. That is the declaratory theory put to work honestly: the facts are entered as they occur, and anyone may read them.
The source
The state as a person of international law should possess the following qualifications: (a) a permanent population; (b) a defined territory; (c) government; and (d) capacity to enter into relations with the other states. … The political existence of the state is independent of recognition by the other states.Convention on the Rights and Duties of States, Montevideo, 26 December 1933, articles 1 and 3 · 165 L.N.T.S. 19.
Key terms
- Montevideo Convention
- The treaty of 1933 that gives the usual four qualifications of a state.
- Declaratory theory
- A state exists once it meets the qualifications; recognition only declares it.
- Constitutive theory
- A state exists in law only when other states recognise it.
- Recognition
- A state’s political decision to treat another body as a state, a government or a party.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Montevideo Convention, Declaratory theory, Constitutive theory, Recognition.