Courses · LAW 301 Outside the Act · Lesson 4 of 4
Where the Act stops
Lecture 4 of 4 · about 6 minutes
Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.
- Under which head of power is the Indian Act made?
- In the Act, title to a reserve is vested in…
- What does the Nation ask of members who also have status?
The Indian Act is a statute of Parliament made under section 91(24) of the Constitution Act, 1867, which gives Parliament authority over “Indians, and Lands reserved for the Indians”. Like any statute it reaches only as far as its words and its constitutional footing allow. This lesson marks the edges.
First, persons. The Act governs “Indians”, those registered or entitled to be registered, and bands. A person who is not an “Indian” in that sense is not governed by it as one, whatever his or her ancestry. Most of the posterity of the Loyalist Mohawk are in that position.
Second, lands. The Act governs reserves: a reserve being “a tract of land, the legal title to which is vested in Her Majesty, that has been set apart by Her Majesty for the use and benefit of a band”. That is the language of a trust, with the Crown as holder. The Nation says the Tract was never such land. It was given, and what was given cannot afterwards be “set apart” by the giver.
Third, the Constitution. A statute cannot override it. If the Proclamation’s grant is an interest preserved by section 109, then neither the Indian Act nor any dealing under it could take that interest from those who hold it. Section 52 makes the inconsistent law of no force to that extent.
Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Section 91(24)” means. Then read on.
There is a practical lesson in this for anyone who descends from the class and also has status. The two do not merge. Status brings what the Act provides. The hereditary interest stands apart from it. The Nation asks its people to keep the two sets of papers, and the two arguments, separate, and never to describe the hereditary interest in the Act’s vocabulary: no “band”, no “reserve”, no “held in trust”.
Finally, the limits of this course’s claim. It does not say the Indian Act is invalid, nor that those under it are wrong to rely on it. It says the Act was written for a class defined by statute, and that another class, defined eighty-seven years earlier by Crown instrument, lies outside it. Two different things can both exist. The difficulty of the last century and a half is that only one of them was ever written into the lists.
For an essay or a moot, take one edge at a time: persons, lands, the Constitution. State what the Act says, then what the Nation says lies beyond, and then the strongest objection to the Nation’s view. A position you can state against yourself is one you understand.
Key terms
- Section 91(24)
- Parliament’s power over “Indians, and Lands reserved for the Indians”.
- Reserve
- In the Act, land vested in the Crown and set apart for a band’s use and benefit.
- Vocabulary
- The words a statute uses; to adopt them is to stand inside it.
Check yourself
Summary
Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Section 91(24), Reserve, Vocabulary.