Mohawk Nation of Grand RiverMohawk UniversityStart learning

Courses · LAW 301 Outside the Act · Lesson 2 of 4

How the Act removed people

Lecture 2 of 4 · about 6 minutes

Before you begin, ask yourself. The lecture answers these questions, and you will meet them again at the end.

  1. Before 1985, a woman with status who married a man without it…
  2. Did the Act ask who descended from the 1779 villages?
  3. In what year was the Indian Act passed?

The Indian Act of 1876 defined who was an “Indian” in Canadian law. For over a century a woman who married a man without status lost hers, and so did her children.

Bill C-31 in 1985 began to undo that, and later amendments went further. But the Nation notes that the Act never asked who descended from the 1779 villages: it was never written for the class.

The definition printed below is the heart of it. From 1876 an “Indian” was, first, a male person of Indian blood reputed to belong to a band; second, his child; third, his wife. Status ran through men. A woman’s status depended on her father and then on her husband.

The Act also provided ways out. Enfranchisement turned an “Indian” into an ordinary subject, with the loss of status for the man, his wife and his children; at times it was compulsory for those who took a degree or a profession. Each enfranchisement removed a family from the lists for good.

The Act’s changes in order. Each point is an amendment; the label says whom it removed or restored.
1876Status through themale line1951A centralRegister;marrying-outsharpened1985Bill C-31:restored, with acut-off2010Bill C-3, afterMcIvor2019Bill S-3, afterDescheneaux

Pause. Look away from the page and say in your own words what “Indian Act” means. Then read on.

In 1951 the Act was rewritten and a central Indian Register created. The marrying-out rule was kept and sharpened. Under it, generations of women and their children were struck off, while women with no Indigenous ancestry who married status men were added.

Bill C-31 in 1985 ended the marrying-out rule for the future and restored many, but it introduced the “second-generation cut-off”: two successive generations of parenting with a person without status, and the grandchildren have none. Further amendments followed court challenges: Bill C-3 in 2010 after McIvor, and Bill S-3, in force fully in 2019, after Descheneaux.

Through all of it the question the Act asked was never the one the Proclamation asks. The Act asked who belonged to a band, through whom, and by what marriage. The Proclamation asks who descends from the class. A statute that never asked the question cannot be the record of its answer.

The numbers show the scale. More than a hundred thousand people regained or gained status in the years after Bill C-31, which tells you how many had been removed or left out before it. Each of those families had been living, in the meantime, as people the Act did not see. For the Loyalist Mohawk posterity the lesson is double. Many were among those removed. And restoration under the Act, where it came, restored status only: it said nothing about, and had no power over, the hereditary interest that this University teaches.

The source

The term “Indian” means, First. Any male person of Indian blood reputed to belong to a particular band; Secondly. Any child of such person; Thirdly. Any woman who is or was lawfully married to such person.
The Indian Act, 1876, s. 3(3) · SC 1876, c 18.

Key terms

Indian Act
Canada’s 1876 statute defining and governing “Indians” and bands.
Bill C-31
The 1985 amendment that began restoring status lost through marriage.
Enfranchisement
Loss of status in exchange for the ordinary rights of a subject.

Check yourself

1.Before 1985, a woman with status who married a man without it…
2.Did the Act ask who descended from the 1779 villages?
3.In what year was the Indian Act passed?

Send to your teacher

Opens your own email with your answers written in. Nothing is sent to or kept by the University.

Summary

Go back to the questions at the top. You should now be able to answer each in a sentence, and to explain these terms: Indian Act, Bill C-31, Enfranchisement.